Graham's Magazine, Vol. XVIII, No. 4, April 1841Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XVIII, No. 4, April 1841
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
_“Heads of the People: or Portraits of the English.” Drawn by
Kenny Meadows. With Original Essays by Distinguished Writers.
Carey & Hart._
The design of this book is among the number of those which are
_obviously_ good—and the book itself is, upon the whole, an amusing
one. It might have been better, no doubt. With designs by Cruikshanks,
and letter-press by _the best_ of the English literati, how glorious a
work might have been concocted “upon this hint!” Not that some of the
names here found are _not_ among the best—but we should have had the
_Dii majorum gentium_ exclusively—one paper from each. These papers,
too, should have been written with some uniformity of manner, or of
plan, and have confined themselves to racy and truthful delineation of
that character which is _peculiarly_ British, while the engravings
should have been careful embodiments of the text. As it is, the
publication has something of a hap-hazard, and, if the truth must be
told, of a catchpenny air, which makes very much against it,
notwithstanding the exceeding merit of several of the essays, and of
three or four of the designs. The preface seems to have been written by
some one who had a proper sense of what the volume _should be_, but
affords no indication of what it really _is_.
There are twenty-six “Heads” in all. Some of them are pure caricatures
without merit—“The Creditor,” for example, and “The Debtor,”
(injudiciously placed as frontispieces), The “Diner-Out,” The
“Sentimental Singer,” “The Man of Many Goes” and “The Printer’s Devil.”
Others are equally caricatures, but of so vivid and truth-preserving an
exaggeration, that we admire without scruple:—we allude to “The Lion of
the Party,” “The Waiter,” “The Linen-Draper’s Assistant” and “The
Stock-Broker.” Some are full of natural truth—for instance “The Young
Lord,” “The Dress-Maker,” “The Young Squire,” “The Basket Woman,”
“Captain Rook” and “Mr. Pigeon.” “The Last Go” is the best thing in the
volume—combining the extreme of the ludicrous with absolute fidelity.
“The Fashionable Authoress,” “The Cockney” and “The Family Governess”
are tame and unmeaning. The rest have no particular merit or demerit.
About the whole there is a great deal of bad drawing, which we know not
whether to attribute to the designer or engraver.
The same variety of value is observable in the text. In general the
articles are not very creditable; although one or two are of surpassing
excellence. The longest called “Tavern Heads” (illustrated by seven or
eight sketches) is a rambling, disjointed narrative in imitation of
Dickens, and written probably by the author of a clever production
entitled “Pickwick Abroad,” never yet republished, we believe, in this
country. The paper called “Captain Rook and Mr. Pigeon,” and
superscribed with the name of William Thackeray, is one of the finest
specimens of easily-mingled humor and wit we have ever had the pleasure
of perusing.
* * * * *
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account