Graham's Magazine, Vol. XXI, No. 3, September 1842 — John Shaqi
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XXI, No. 3, September 1842Various
General
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XXI, No. 3, September 1842
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
As it is, by fair means or foul, the weekly newspaper press, with its
broad sheet spread to the breeze, is making great head against the
slow-sailing progress of such as trust to the more regular trade-winds
for their speed. And this, fortunately (as error cannot long abide in
itself,) is creating changes of opinion of infinite advantage to the
great cause of international copyright.
A little while ago, we had the publishers petitioning and declaiming
against an international copyright, (I forget what arguments they
employed;) and, lo! their breath is scarcely spent when the ground
slides from under them, and the whole publishing business—at least a
considerable section of it—which they meant to uphold by false and
hollow props, has tumbled into chaos, and an organic change has passed
through the world of publication. Now they begin—and we are glad to
have so powerful and so respectable a body convert to our side, on
whatever terms—to see the matter in a new light; the affection for the
people, and the cheap enlightenment of the people, and the people’s
wives and children, which they made bold (out of an exceeding
philanthropy) to proclaim in market-places and the lobbies of Congress,
is wonderfully dwindled.
It isn’t a pleasant thing, after all, to have one’s printing-house and
bindery burned to the ground, even for so laudable an object. Suppose we
have the law: a little civilized recognition of the rights of authors
(merely by way of clincher, however, to the absolute, primary and
indefeasible rights of publishers) might be an agreeable change from
this barbarous system of non-protection. The old plan, it must be
admitted, has its disadvantages. Let’s have the law! And here you may
suppose the hats of certain old, respected and enterprising publishers
to rise into the air, in a sort of fervor or ecstasy, which it is
entirely out of their power to control.
Is there or is there not a property in a book: a primitive, real,
fundamental right in its ownership as in any estate or property? Often
and clearly as this question has been determined, the opponents of a
law, by stress of argument, are driven upon denying it over and over
again, and making use of every sort of ridiculous and irrelevant
illustration to crowd the right out of the way. They fly into all
corners of creation in pursuit of an analogy, and come back without as
much as a sparrow in their bag.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account