Graham's Magazine, Vol. XXI, No. 6, December 1842Various
History
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XXI, No. 6, December 1842
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
The inventory of Commodore Barry’s personal property is very
minute, containing articles of a value as low as one dollar. It
mentions _two_ swords, both of which are specifically
bequeathed—viz. “_my_ gold-hilted” and “_my_ silver-hilted
sword.” No allusion is made in the will to any trust. Only these
two swords were found among the assets, and each was delivered
agreeably to the bequest. The gold-hilted sword was known in the
family, as the “Paul Jones sword,” and there is not the smallest
doubt Commodore Barry intended to bequeath this particular
sword, in full property, to Commodore Dale.
Let us next look to the probabilities of the case. The heirs of
Paul Jones, who left no issue, gave the sword to Robert Morris,
says Captain Mackenzie, as a mark of gratitude. This may very
well be true. But Mr. Morris “gave the sword to the navy of the
United States,” to be retained and worn by its senior officer.
It would have been a more usual course to have lodged the sword
in the Navy Department, had such been the intention. That
Commodore Barry did not view _his_ possession of the sword in
this light, is clear enough by his will. He gave it, _without_
restraint of any sort, to a friend who was not in the navy at
all, and who never had been its senior officer. This he did, in
full possession of his mind and powers, six months before he
died, and under circumstances to render any misconception highly
improbable.
Can we find any motive for the bequest of Commodore Barry? It
was not personal to himself, as the sword went out of his own
family. The _other sword_ he gave to a brother-in-law. “Paul
Jones’ sword” was bequeathed to a distinguished professional
friend—to one who, of all others, next to Jones himself, had
the best professional right to wear it—to “Paul Jones’ first
lieutenant.” Commodore Dale did leave sons, and some in the
navy; and the country will believe that the one who now owns the
sword has as good a moral right to wear it, as the remote
collaterals of Jones, and a much better right than the senior
officer of the navy, on proof as vague as that offered. His
_legal_ right to the sword seems to be beyond dispute.
In the inventory of Commodore Barry’s personals, this sword is
thus mentioned, viz.—“a very elegant gold-hilted sword—$300.”
The other sword is thus mentioned, viz.—“a handsome
silver-hilted, do. $100.”
* * * * *
THE SERENADE.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account