Graham's Magazine, Vol. XXX, No. 4, April 1847Various
History
Graham's Magazine, Vol. XXX, No. 4, April 1847
Various
Literature -- Periodicals; Literature, Modern -- 19th century -- Periodicals
own freedom, which feeling is its Baphometic Baptism: the citadel of its
whole kingdom it has thus gained by assault, and will keep inexpungable;
outward from which the remaining dominions, not, indeed, without hard
battling, will doubtless by degrees be conquered and pacificated.”
Beside some philosophers of larger vision, Carlyle stands like an
honest, half-despairing boy, grasping at some details only of their
world systems. Philosophy, certainly, is some account of truths, the
fragments and very insignificant parts of which man will practice in
this work-shop; truths infinite and in harmony with infinity; in respect
to which the very objects and ends of the so-called practical
philosopher, will be mere propositions, like the rest. It would be no
reproach to a philosopher, that he knew the future better than the past,
or even than the present. It is better worth knowing. He will prophecy,
tell what is to be, or in other words, what alone is, under appearances,
laying little stress on the boiling of the pot, or the Condition of
England question. He has no more to do with the condition of England
than with her national debt, which a vigorous generation would not
inherit. The philosopher’s conception of things will, above all, be
truer than other men’s, and his philosophy will subordinate all the
circumstances of life. To live like a philosopher, is to live, not
foolishly, like other men, but wisely, and according to universal laws.
In this, which was the ancient sense, we think there has been no
philosopher in modern times. The wisest and most practical men of recent
history, to whom this epithet has been hastily applied, have lived
comparatively meagre lives, of conformity and tradition, such as their
fathers transmitted to them. But a man may live in what style he can.
Between earth and heaven, there is room for all kinds. If he take
counsel of fear and prudence, he has already failed. One who believed,
by his very constitution, some truth which a few words express, would
make a revolution never to be forgotten in this world; for it needs but
a fraction of truth to found houses and empires on.
However, such distinctions as poet and philosopher, do not much assist
our final estimate of a man; we do not lay much stress on them. “A man’s
a man for a’ that.” If Carlyle does not take two steps in philosophy,
are there any who take three? Philosophy having crept clinging to the
rocks, so far, puts out its feelers many ways in vain. It would be hard
to surprise him by the relation of any important human experience, but
in some nook or corner of his works, you will find that this, too, was
sometimes dreamed of in his philosophy.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account