Half Hours With Modern Scientists: Lectures and EssaysTyndall, John
Philosophy
Half Hours With Modern Scientists: Lectures and Essays
Tyndall, John
Science
Demurring, then, to Mr. Huxley’s opinion on this matter, and postponing
remark on the doctrines to which he alludes, I must express a hearty
concurrence with every word he utters on Comte. In him I too “find
little or nothing of any scientific value.” I too have been lost in the
mere mirage and sands of “those dreary and verbose pages;” and I
acknowledge in Mr. Huxley’s every word the ring of a genuine experience.
M. Comte was certainly a man of some mathematical and scientific
proficiency, as well as of quick but biased intelligence. A member of
the _Aufklärung_, he had seen the immense advance of physical science
since Newton, under, as is usually said, the method of Bacon; and, like
Hume, like Reid, like Kant, _who had all anticipated him in this_, he
sought to transfer that method to the domain of mind. In this he failed;
and though in a sociological aspect he is not without true glances into
the present disintegration of society and the conditions of it, anything
of importance cannot be claimed for him. There is not a sentence in his
book that, in the hollow elaboration and windy pretentiousness of its
build, is not an exact type of its own constructor. On the whole,
indeed, when we consider the little to which he attained, the empty
inflation of his claims, the monstrous and maniacal self-conceit into
which he was _exalted_, it may appear, perhaps, that charity to M. Comte
himself, to say nothing of the world, should induce us to wish that both
his name and his works were buried in oblivion. Now, truly, that Mr.
Huxley (the “call” being for the moment his) has so pronounced himself,
especially as the facts of the case are exactly and absolutely what he
indicates, perhaps we may expect this consummation not to be so very
long delayed. More than those members of the revulsion already
mentioned, one is apt to suspect, will be anxious now to beat a retreat.
Not that this, however, is so certain to be allowed them; for their
estimate of M. Comte is a valuable element in the estimate of
themselves.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account