34. Livy says (xxi. 31) that after getting across the Rhone, Hannibal
marched up the other bank towards the interior of Gaul, whereas
Polybios says (iii. 47. 1) that he marched eastward (_hôs epi tên heô_)
going along the river up-stream. (His phrase for “up-stream” here is
“away from the sea, towards the interior of Europe,” and in iii. 39.
9, speaking of the same march, his phrase is “towards the sources.”)
Livy has put Gaul for Europe, and omitted “eastward.” But if Hannibal
marched eastward here, he must have marched along the Durance, not the
Rhone, as the Durance here runs from east to west and the Rhone from
north to south. No doubt, Polybios says (iii. 47. 2, 3) that the Rhone
had its sources on the north side of the Alps, its sources facing west
(_pros tên hesperan_), and that its course was south-west (_pros tas
cheimerinas dyseis_) to the sea. And as a general statement, that is
true; but if he had imagined that the Rhone was running south-west
at the point where Hannibal crossed it, he surely would have said
that Hannibal marched north-east--he would not distinguish west and
south-west in one sentence and confound east and north-east in the next.
35. According to Polybios (iii. 49. 5, 8–13) Hannibal marched in four
days from the crossing of the Rhone to the so-called Island between
the Rhone and the Scôras, found a civil-war in progress there, joined
one faction in crushing the other, and obtained supplies from the
successful faction as the price of his support. He must have crossed
the Scôras and marched into the Island, as Polybios says “joined in
attacking and expelling”--_synepithemenos kai synekbalôn_--which
certainly implies that he did something more than make a demonstration
from the other bank. And if the crossing over was comprised in the four
days, the march may have been less than 40 Roman miles at 10 Roman
miles a day: see paragraph 3.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account