Hans Holbein the Younger, Volume 2 (of 2)Chamberlain, Arthur B. (Arthur Bensley)
History
Hans Holbein the Younger, Volume 2 (of 2)
Chamberlain, Arthur B. (Arthur Bensley)
Holbein, Hans, 1497-1543 -- Criticism and interpretation; Painters -- Germany -- Biography
The probable authorship of this painting has given rise to much
discussion and difference of opinion. It has been attributed at
different times to Holbein, Janet, Joos van Cleve, and Girolamo da
Treviso, and even to Toto or Penni. Dr. Woltmann considered it to be the
work of a Frenchman, whereas Mr. Wornum was inclined to attribute it to
an Italian hand, possibly Da Treviso. The one thing certain about it is
that it is not by Holbein. There is an equal difference of opinion as to
the date. The King has so youthful a look, as compared with the Hardwick
cartoon and the Munich drawing, that some writers hold that he cannot
have been more than thirty-eight—certainly not more than forty—when it
was painted. This would make the date about 1529, in which year Holbein
was in Switzerland. On the other hand, there are two facts which point
to a later date—the arrangement of the hair and beard, and the text on
the scroll, which, taken together, make it highly probable that the
portrait was painted in 1536. It was on the 8th of May 1535 that Henry,
in imitation of Francis I, ordered all about his court to cut their hair
short and to grow their beards—“the King commanded all about his court
to poll their heads; and to give them example he caused his own head to
be polled, and from thenceforth his beard to be knotted and no more
shaven.”[234] In the picture both hair and beard are treated in the new
fashion. Again, on October 4th of the same year the printing of
Coverdale’s English version of the whole Bible, for which Holbein
designed the title-page, was finished, and in 1536 Henry ordered a copy
of it to be laid in the choir of every church, “for every man that will
to look and read therein; and shall discourage no man from reading any
part of the Bible, but rather comfort, exhort, and admonish every man to
read the same.” To this the text on the scroll which Henry holds in the
portrait clearly refers; and further evidence is supplied by the Bible
frontispiece, in which the King is shown under a canopy, with a sword in
his right hand, and a clasped Bible in his left, which he is handing to
his kneeling bishops. One of the little pictures which form the border
of the title-page, in which our Saviour is exhorting His disciples to
preach the Word throughout the world, has the same text (Mark xvi. 15)
inscribed below it. The evidence, therefore, is very strongly in favour
of the assumption that the portrait was painted to commemorate Henry’s
share in the publication of Coverdale’s English version of the Bible.
Against these two arguments in favour of the date 1536, the compilers of
the catalogue of the Burlington Fine Arts Club Exhibition point out that
the King does not look more than thirty, which would place the portrait
at about the date of the meeting with Francis I at the Field of the
Cloth of Gold in 1520. “The portrait of Eleonora of Spain, wife of
Francis I, also at Hampton Court,” they say, “is evidently by the same
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account