Hans Holbein the Younger, Volume 2 (of 2)Chamberlain, Arthur B. (Arthur Bensley)
History
Hans Holbein the Younger, Volume 2 (of 2)
Chamberlain, Arthur B. (Arthur Bensley)
Holbein, Hans, 1497-1543 -- Criticism and interpretation; Painters -- Germany -- Biography
“The picture by Holbein,” says Sir George, “could only have been a
drawing or a painting on rather a small scale, inasmuch as it had at
once to be conveyed by a messenger to England, and one of the objects of
Hutton’s letter was to show the diligence with which the King’s commands
were executed and to announce the coming of the picture. The scale and
workmanship of the picture before us are exactly such as might have been
expected from a first-rate painter and tactician under such
circumstances. All essential points are observed with scrupulous
fidelity, and, certainly, as far as internal evidence extends, without
flattery. It is not to be supposed that Holbein did nothing to the
picture beyond the term of the three hours’ sitting afforded by the
Duchess. Having secured all the essential points of likeness, and given
the general colouring, he doubtless spent some time in further
finishings from memory. But time must have been given for the picture to
dry.”
Wornum, however, refuses to accept Sir George’s ascription. “The head is
vigorously painted,” he says, “and very natural; it shows, however, no
complete finish, which, if the picture referred to, is exactly what one
would expect; but it lacks also the mastery one would expect to find in
a free sketch by Holbein. The hands are inferior, but they appear to
have been partly repainted; the background has also been entirely
repainted.... In its present state, it looks much more like a clever
study from the Arundel picture, than its pattern; anyhow the distance
between them is immense, but this does not prove much, for a very
inferior master to Holbein could elaborate a magical effect from a mere
rough sketch, provided this possessed the real germs of truth in
it.”[268]
Footnote 268:
Wornum, p. 313.
[Sidenote: PORTRAIT OF THE DUCHESS AT WINDSOR]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account