Harper's New Monthly Magazine, No. XXVII, August 1852, Vol. VVarious
History
Harper's New Monthly Magazine, No. XXVII, August 1852, Vol. V
Various
American literature -- Periodicals; Civilization -- Periodicals; Culture -- Periodicals
It might, at first, seem strange that this should be so. The
emotions of benevolence, of compassion, of patriotism, it might be
said, must be the same whatever calls them forth. But a true
analysis will show that there is not only a great but an essential
difference. In the one case feeling is the natural result of a sound
soul in direct communion with the realities of life. In the other it
is entirely artificial.--One has its ground in the reason and the
conscience; the other in the sensitive and imaginative nature. One
comes to us in the due course of things; the other we create for
ourselves. The one is ever recuperative, elevating while it humbles,
softening while it invigorates. It grows stronger and purer by
exercise. It never satiates, never exhausts, never reacts. The other
ever produces an exhaustion corresponding to the unnatural
excitement, and like every other artificial stimulus reduces the
spiritual nature to a lower state at every repetition. In short, to
use the expressive Scriptural comparisons, the one is a continual
pouring into broken cisterns; the other is like a well of _living
water_, springing up to everlasting life. Nothing is more alluringly
deceptive, and therefore more dangerous, than the cultivation of the
æsthetic nature, either to the exclusion of the moral, or by
cherishing a public sentiment that confounds them together. We
should be warned by the fact, of which history furnishes more than
one example, that a nation may be distinguished for artistic and
dramatic refinement, and yet present the most horrid contrast of
crime and cruelty. A similar view may be taken of an age noted for a
theoretical, or sentimental, or theatrical philanthropy. There is
great reason to fear that it will be followed, if not accompanied,
by one distinguished for great ferocity and recklessness of actual
human suffering.
But to return to our analogy. It might with equal justice be
maintained, in respect to the body, that physical _strength_ is the
same, whatever the cause by which it is produced. And yet we all
know that there is a most essential difference between that vigor of
nerve and muscle which is the result of the real and natural
exercise of the healthy organism, in the performance of its
legitimate functions, and that which comes from maddening artificial
stimulants. They may appear the same for the moment; and yet we know
that the one has an element of invigorating and _re-creating_ life;
the other has the seeds of death, and brings death into the human
microcosm with all its train of physical as well as spiritual woes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account