Harper's New Monthly Magazine, No. XXVII, August 1852, Vol. VVarious
History
Harper's New Monthly Magazine, No. XXVII, August 1852, Vol. V
Various
American literature -- Periodicals; Civilization -- Periodicals; Culture -- Periodicals
And this suggests that idea in which we find the most interior
difference between true and false feeling. In the one the emotion is
sought for its own sake as an _end_. In the other it is the _means_
to a higher good. One seeks to save its life and loses it. The other
loses its life and finds it. The true benevolence is unconscious of
itself as an end, and through such unconsciousness attains to
substantial satisfaction. The spurious looks to nothing but the
luxury of its own emotion, and thus continually transmutes into
poison the very aliment on which it feeds. Like Milton's incestuous
monsters, so do the matricidal pleasures of artificial sentiment.
Into the womb
That bred them ever more return--
engendering, in the end, a fiercer want, and giving birth to a more
intolerable pain--
Hourly conceived
And hourly born with sorrow infinite.
There, too, we find the right notion of that word which would seem
so incapable of all strict definition--we mean the much-used and
much-abused term, _sentimentalism_. It differs from true feeling in
this, that it is a _feeling to feel_--or, for the sake of feeling--a
_feeling of one's own feelings_ (if we may use the strange
expression), instead of the woes and sufferings of others, which are
not strictly the _objects_, but only the _means_ of luxurious
excitement, to this introverted state of the affections. Hence,
while true benevolence ever goes forth in the freedom of its
unconsciousness, sentimentalism is ever most egotistical, ever
turning inward to gaze upon itself, and _feel itself_, and thus ever
more in the most rigorous and ignominious bondage.
The same position, had we time, might be taken in respect to what
may be styled false, or theatrical mirth. Even mirth, which, under
other circumstances, and when produced by other causes, might be an
innocent and healthful recreation, is here utterly spoiled, because
we know it to be all _acting_. It is all false; there is no reality
in it; there is no true merry heart there. To the right feeling,
there is even a thought of sadness in the spectacle, when we reflect
how often amid the wearisome repetition of what must be to him the
same stale buffoonery, the soul of the wretched actor may be
actually aching, and bitterly aching, beneath his comic mask.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account