Harvard Psychological Studies, Volume 2 — John Shaqi
Harvard Psychological Studies, Volume 2
Science
Harvard Psychological Studies, Volume 2
Psychology, Experimental
But Emerson stands smiling behind this group of admirers and says,
"To be great is to be misunderstood." Yes, he did say, "A foolish
consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little
statesmen and philosophers and divines;" but he soon adds, "Of one
will the actions will be harmonious however unlike they seem." Emerson
despises the consistency of the surface because he holds to the
consistency of the depths, and every sentence he speaks is an action of
the one will, and however unlike they seem they are harmonious, and, we
can add, they are philosophical; and, what may seem to these anxious
friends more daring, they are not only in harmony with each other,
they are in deepest harmony with the spirit of modern philosophy, with
a creed which ought to be taught by the most critical scholars of
Harvard's Philosophy Hall.
What is the essence of Emerson's doctrine in the realm of philosophy?
It seems like sacrilege to formulate anything he said in the dry terms
of technical philosophy. We must tear from it all the richness and
splendor of his style, we must throw off the glory of his metaphor, and
we must leave out his practical wisdom and his religious emotion. It
seems as if we must lose all we love. It is as if we were to take a
painting of Raphael and abstract not only from the richly colored gowns
of the persons in it, but from their flesh and blood, till only the
skeletons of the figures remained. All beauty would be gone, and yet we
know that Raphael himself drew at first the skeletons of his figures,
knowing too well that no pose and no gesture is convincing, and no
drapery beautiful if the bones and joints fit not correctly together.
And such a skeleton of theoretical ideas appears not only without
charm, it appears necessarily also uninteresting, without originality,
commonplace. All the philosophies, from Plato to Hegel, brought down to
their technical formulas, sound merely like new combinations of trivial
elements, and yet they have made the world, have made revolutions and
wars, have led to freedom and peace, have been mightier than traditions
and customs; and it is true for every one of them that, as Emerson
said, "A philosopher must be more than a philosopher."
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account