_June 13._--Seyd Ali breakfasted with us. Looking at one of the
plates in Hutton's _Mathematical Dictionary_, where there was a
figure of a fountain produced by the rarefaction of the air, he
inquired into the principle of it, which I explained; he
disputed the principle, and argued for the exploded idea that
nature abhors a vacuum. We soon got upon religion again. I
showed him some verses in the Koran in which Mohammed disclaims
the power of working miracles. He could not reply. We talked
again on the evidence of testimony. The oldest book written by a
Mohammedan was the sermons of Ali. Allowing these sermons to be
really his, I objected to his testimony for Mohammed, because he
was interested in the support of that religion. I asked him the
meaning of a contested passage; he gave the usual explanation;
but as soon as the servants were gone he turned round and said,
'It is only to make a rhyme.' This conversation seemed to be
attended with good. Our amiable host, Jaffir Ali, Mirza Jan, and
Seyd Ali seemed to be delighted with my arguments against
Mohammedanism, and did not at last evince a wish to defend it.
In the evening Jaffir Ali came and talked most agreeably on
religious subjects, respecting the obvious tendency of piety and
impiety, and the end to which they would lead in a future world.
One of his remarks was, 'If I am in love with any one, I shall
dream of her at night; her image will meet me in my sleep. Now
death is but a sleep; if therefore I love God, or Christ, when I
fall asleep in death I shall meet Him, so also if I love Satan
or his works.' He could wish, he said, if he had not a wife and
children, to go and live on the top of a mountain, so disgusted
was he with the world and its concerns. I told him this was the
first suggestion in the minds of devotees in all religions, but
that in reality it was not the way to escape the pollution of
the world, because a man's wicked heart will go with him to the
top of a mountain. It is the grace of God changing the heart
which will alone raise us above the world. Christ commands His
people to 'abide in Him'; this is the secret source of
fruitfulness, without which they are as branches cut off from
the tree. He asked whether there was no mention of a prophet's
coming after Christ. I said, No. 'Why then,' said he, 'was any
mention made of Ahmed in the Koran?' He said, 'One day an
English gentleman said to me, "I believe that Christ was no
better than myself." "Why then," said I, "you are worse than a
Mohammedan."'
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account