Hilaire Belloc, the man and his workMandell, C. Creighton
History
Hilaire Belloc, the man and his work
Mandell, C. Creighton
Belloc, Hilaire, 1870-1953 -- Criticism and interpretation
It is his opinion, we say, or rather one of the articles of his creed,
that Rome first beat and welded into unity the kindred peoples that
inhabit Western Europe. What name he gives to this Western race, if any,
he has not yet explained. Professor Mueller and his contemporaries used
to talk about the Indo-Germanic race, and Professor Sergi came forward
with a more plausible Mediterranean race, and all sorts of people talk
with the utmost possible vagueness about the Celtic race, that
rubbish-heap of ethnological science or pretence. Whatever name he may
give to this race, or however ethnologically he may justify his
conception of it, Mr. Belloc believes that it exists and that Rome first
discovered it and gave it expression.
Like all large and generalized conceptions, this idea of the Western
race is best explained in a contrast, and Mr. Belloc finds a sharp
example of such a contrast in the struggle between Rome and Carthage. He
sets it out in _Esto Perpetua_:
It [the Phoenician attempt] failed for two reasons: the first was
the contrast between the Phoenician ideal and our own; the second
was the solidarity of the Western blood.
The army which Hannibal led recognized the voice of a Carthaginian
genius, but it was not Carthaginian. It was not levied, it was
paid. Even those elements in it which were native to Carthage or
her colonies must receive a wage, must be "volunteer"; and
meanwhile the policy which directed the whole from the centre in
Africa was a trading policy. Rome "interfered with business"; on
this account alone the costly and unusual effort of removing her
was made.
The Europeans undertook their defence in a very different spirit:
an abhorrence of this alien blood welded them together: the allied
and subjugated cities which had hated Rome had hated her as a
sister.
The Italian confederation was true because it rested on other than
economic supports. The European passion for military glory survived
every disaster, and above all that wholly European thing, the
delight in meeting great odds, made our people strangely stronger
for defeat.
It is in the European spirit, the spirit of "our people," that Mr.
Belloc finds the mission and the justification of Rome. It is on a
belief in the reality of this spirit that he founds his views of all
subsequent developments, of our own present and of our future. The work
of Rome has been minimized in common estimation by our extraordinary
habit of telescoping the centuries and viewing history, as we say, in a
perspective. There is no perspective in a right view of history: the
centuries do not diminish in length as they recede from our own day. The
perception of this very simple fact has not come to many of our
historians or to any of our politicians. It should be, indeed, the first
sentence in every school history-book, and the don should begin each
course of lectures with it.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account