But the light must have its attendant shadow, and all his carefulness
in observation and cautiousness in judgment did not protect him from
one prejudice and its evil consequences. After Moldenhawer had isolated
the elementary organs by maceration, he had to answer the question how
we are to conceive of their firm coherence in the living plant. He came
to the conclusion, as did von Mohl, Schacht, and others after him,
that there must be some special connecting medium; but he did not hit
upon their idea of a matrix, in which the cells are imbedded, or of a
cement which holds them together, but on a much stranger theory, which
reminds us at once of Grew’s thread-tissue, and like that rests partly
on incorrect observations. These were too hastily accepted as the basis
of a theory which in its turn interfered with after observations. He
thought that the cells and vessels were surrounded and held together
by an extremely delicate network of fine fibres; in some cases he
really believed that he saw these fibres, and interpreted in this way
the thickened bands in the well-known cells of Sphagnum, and still
more strangely he appears to have taken the thickened longitudinal
and transverse edges of cells and vessels for such threads. The
unfavourable impression produced by this theory is necessarily
heightened by the fact that he gave the name of cell-tissue, a term
long used in a different sense, to his fancy-structure of reticulated
threads which were to hold the cells and vessels together, while he
called the parenchyma itself cellular substance, an expression which
fortunately no one copied, and which certainly contributed at a later
time to discredit the great services which Moldenhawer rendered to
phytotomy.
His ‘Beiträge zur Anatomie der Pflanzen’ are divided into two portions;
the first treats of the parts surrounding the spiral vessels; the
second of the spiral vessels themselves.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account