History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)Taine, Hippolyte
History
History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)
Taine, Hippolyte
English literature -- History and criticism
We see the trumps, the cuts, the tricks, and instantly afterwards the
coffee, the china, the spoons, the fiery spirits (to wit, spirits of
wine); we have here in advance the modes and periphrases of Delille. The
celebrated verses in which Delille at once employs and describes
imitative harmony are translated from Pope.[37] It is an expiring
poetry, but poetry still: an ornament to put on a mantelpiece is an
inferior work of art, but still it is a work of art. To descriptive
talent Pope unites oratorical talent. This art, proper to the classical
age, is the art of expressing ordinary general ideas. For a hundred and
fifty years men of both the thinking countries, England and France,
employed herein all their study. They seized those universal and limited
truths, which, being situated between lofty philosophical abstractions
and petty sensible details, are the subject-matter of eloquence and
rhetoric, and form what we nowadays call commonplaces. They arranged
them in compartments; methodically developed them; made them obvious by
grouping and symmetry; disposed them in regular processions, which with
dignity and majesty advanced well disciplined, and in a body. The
influence of this oratorical reason became so great that it was imposed
on poetry itself. Buffon ends by saying, in praise of certain verses,
that they are as fine as fine prose. In fact, poetry at this time became
a more affected prose subjected to rhyme. It was only a higher kind of
conversation and more select discourse. It is powerless when it is
necessary to paint or represent an action, when the need is to see and
make visible living passions, large genuine emotions, men of flesh and
blood; it results only in college epics like the "Henriade," freezing
odes and tragedies like those of Voltaire and Jean-Baptiste Rousseau, or
those of Addison, Thomson, Dr. Johnson, and the rest. It makes them up
of dissertations, because it is capable of nothing else but
dissertations. Here henceforth is its domain; and its final task is the
didactic poem, which is a dissertation in verse. Pope excelled in it,
and his most perfect poems are those made up of precepts and arguments.
Artifice in these is less shocking than elsewhere. A poem--I am wrong,
essays like his upon "Criticism," on "Man" and the "Government of
Providence," on the "Knowledge and Characters of Men," deserve to be
written after reflection; they are a study, and almost a scientific
monograph. We may, we even ought, to weigh all the words, and verify all
the connections: art and attention are not superfluous, but necessary;
the question concerns exact precepts and close arguments. In this Pope
is incomparable. I do not think that there is in the world a versified
prose like his; that of Boileau is not to be compared to it. Not that
its ideas are very worthy of attention; we have worn them out, they
interest us no longer. "The Essay on Criticism" resembles Boileau's
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account