History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)Taine, Hippolyte
History
History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)
Taine, Hippolyte
English literature -- History and criticism
And then he tries to resuscitate this soul before our eyes; for this is
his special feature, the special feature of every historian who has the
sentiment of actuality, to understand that parchments, walls, dress,
bodies themselves, are only cloaks and documents; that the true fact is
the inner feeling of men who have lived, that the only important fact is
the state and structure of their soul, that the first and sole business
is to reach that inner feeling, for that all else diverges from it. We
must tell ourselves this fact over and over again; history is but the
history of the heart; we have to search out the feelings of past
generations, and nothing else. This is what Carlyle perceives; man is
before him, risen from the dead; he penetrates within him, sees that he
feels, suffers, and wills, in that special and individual manner, now
absolutely lost and extinguished, in which he did feel, suffer, and
will. And he looks upon this sight, not coldly, like a man who only half
sees things in a gray mist, indistinctly and uncertain, but with all the
force of his heart and sympathy, like a convinced spectator, for whom
past things, once proved, are as present and visible as the corporeal
objects which his hand handles and touches, at the very moment. He feels
this fact so clearly that he bases upon it all his philosophy of
history. In his opinion, great men, kings, writers, prophets, and poets,
are only great in this sense: "It is the property of the hero, in every
time, in every place, in every situation, that he comes back to reality;
that he stands upon things and not shows of things."[346] The great man
discovers some unknown or neglected fact, proclaims it; men hear him,
follow him; and this is the whole of history. And not only does he
discover and proclaim it, but he believes and sees it. He believes it,
not as hearsay or conjecture, like a truth simply probable and handed
down; he sees it personally, face to face with absolute and indomitable
faith; he deserts opinion for conviction, tradition for intuition.
Carlyle is so steeped in his process, that he imputes it to all great
men. And he is not wrong, for there is none more potent. Wherever he
penetrates with this lamp, he carries a light not known before. He
pierces mountains of paper erudition, and enters into the hearts of men.
Everywhere he goes beyond political and conventional history. He divines
characters, comprehends the spirit of extinguished ages, feels, better
than any Englishman, better than Macaulay himself, the great revolutions
of the soul. He is almost German in his power of imagination, his
antiquarian perspicacity, his broad general views, and yet he is no
dealer in guesses. The national common-sense and the energetic craving
for profound belief retain him on the limits of supposition; when he
does guess, he gives it for what it is worth. He has no taste for
hazardous history. He rejects hearsay and legends; he accepts only
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account