History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)Taine, Hippolyte
History
History of English Literature Volume 3 (of 3)
Taine, Hippolyte
English literature -- History and criticism
whose future shade was to shelter his posterity; and he thought with a
poet's smile of the distant generations who would acknowledge for their
ancestor Sir Walter Scott, first baronet of Abbotsford.
"The Lady of the Lake, Marmion, The Lord of the Isles, The Fair Maid of
Perth, Old Mortality, Ivanhoe, Quentin Durward," who does not know these
names by heart? From Walter Scott we learned history. And yet is this
history? All these pictures of a distant age are false. Costumes,
scenery, externals alone are exact; actions, speech, sentiments, all the
rest is civilized, embellished, arranged in modern guise. We might
suspect it when looking at the character and life of the author; for
what does he desire, and what do the guests, eager to hear him, demand?
Is he a lover of truth as it is, foul and fierce; an inquisitive
explorer, indifferent to contemporary applause, bent alone on defining
the transformations of living nature? By no means. He is in history, as
he is at Abbotsford, bent on arranging points of view and Gothic halls.
The moon will come in well there between the towers; here is a nicely
placed breastplate, the ray of light which it throws back is pleasant to
see on these old hangings; suppose we took out the feudal garments from
the wardrobe and invited the guests to a masquerade? The entertainment
would be a fine one, in accordance with their reminiscences and their
aristocratic principles. English lords, fresh from a bitter war against
French democracy, ought to enter zealously into this commemoration of
their ancestors. Moreover, there are ladies and young girls, and we must
arrange the show, so as not to shock their severe morality and their
delicate feelings, make them weep becomingly; not put on the stage
over-strong passions, which they would not understand; on the contrary,
select heroines to resemble them, always touching, but above all
correct; young gentlemen, Evandale, Morton, Ivanhoe, irreproachably
brought up, tender and grave, even slightly melancholic (it is the
latest fashion), and worthy to lead them to the altar. Is there a man
more suited than the author to compose such a spectacle? He is a good
Protestant, a good husband, a good father, very moral, so decided a Tory
that he carries off as a relic a glass from which the king has just
drunk. In addition, he has neither talent nor leisure to reach the
depths of his characters. He devotes himself to the exterior; he sees
and describes forms and externals much more at length than inward
feelings. Again, he treats his mind like a coal-mine, serviceable for
quick working, and for the greatest possible gain: a volume in a month,
sometimes in a fortnight even, and this volume is worth one thousand
pounds. How should he discover, or how dare exhibit, the structure of
barbarous souls? This structure is too difficult to discover, and too
little pleasing to show. Every two centuries, amongst men, the
proportion of images and ideas, the mainspring of passions, the degree
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account