Putting all the statements of Thucydidês together, we may be
convinced that this is the way in which the facts occurred. But
of the precise sense of ὐφορμισάμενοι, I confess I do not feel
certain: Haack says, it means “clam appellere ad littus,” but
here, I think, that sense will not do: for the Peloponnesians did
not wish, and could indeed hardly hope, to conceal from Phormio
the spot where they brought to for the night, and to make him
suppose that they brought to at some point of the shore west of
Patræ, when in reality they passed the night in Patræ,—which
is what Dr. Arnold supposes. The shore west of Patræ makes a
bend to the southwest,—forming the gulf of Patras,—so that the
distance from the northern, or Ætolian and Akarnanian, side of
the gulf becomes for a considerable time longer and longer, and
the Peloponnesians would thus impose upon themselves a longer
crossing, increasing the difficulty of getting over without a
battle. But ὐφορμισάμενοι may reasonably be supposed to mean,
especially in conjunction with οὐκ ἔλαθον, “taking up a simulated
or imperfect night-station,” in which they did not really intend
to stay all night, and which could be quitted at short notice and
with ease. The preposition ὑπὸ, in composition, would thus have
the sense, not of _secrecy_ (_clam_) but of _sham-performance_,
or of mere going through the forms of an act for the purpose of
making a false impression (like ὑποφέρειν, Xenoph. Hell. iv, 72).
Mr. Bloomfield proposes conjecturally ἀφορμισάμενοι, meaning,
“that the Peloponnesians slipped their anchors in the night:” I
place no faith in the conjecture, but I believe him to be quite
right in supposing, that the Peloponnesians _did actually_ slip
their anchors in the night.
Another point remains to be adverted to. The battle took
place κατὰ μέσον τὸν πορθμόν. Now we need not understand this
expression to allude to the narrowest part of the sea, or the
strait, strictly and precisely; that is, the line of seven stadia
between Rhium and Antirrhium. But I think we must understand it
to mean a portion of sea not far westward of the strait, where
the breadth, though greater than that of the strait itself,
is yet not so great as it becomes in the line drawn northward
from Patræ. We cannot understand πορθμὸς (as Mr. Bloomfield and
Poppo do,—see the note of the latter on the Scholia) to mean
_trajectus_ simply, that is to say, the passage across even
the widest portion of the gulf of Patras: nor does the passage
cited out of c. 86 require us so to understand it. Πορθμὸς, in
Thucydidês, means a strait, or narrow crossing of sea, and Poppo
himself admits that Thucydidês always uses it so: nor would it be
reasonable to believe that he would call the line of sea across
the gulf, from Patræ to the mouth of the Euenus, a πορθμός. See
the note of Göller, on this point.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account