Some say that τοῦ μὴ in this place means the same as ὥστε μή:
others affirm, that it is identical with διὰ τὸ μὴ or with τῷ
μή. “Formula ~τοῦ, τοῦ μὴ~ (say Bauer and Göller), plerumque
_consilium_ significat: interdum _effectum_ (_i. e._ ὥστε μή);
hic _causam_ indicat (i. e. διὰ τὸ μὴ, or τῷ μή).” But I agree
with Dr. Arnold in thinking that the last of these three alleged
meanings is wholly unauthorized; while the second, which is
adopted by Dr. Arnold himself, is sustained only by feeble and
dubious evidence; for the passage of Thucydidês (ii, 4. τοῦ μὴ
ἐκφεύγειν) may be as well construed, as Poppo’s note thereupon
suggests, without any such supposed exceptional sense of the
words.
Now it seems to me quite possible to construe the words τοῦ μὴ
φθῆναι here in their regular and legitimate sense of ~ἕνεκα τοῦ~,
or _consilium_. But first an error must be cleared up which
pervades the view of most of the commentators. They suppose that
those Argeians, who are here affirmed to have been “_trodden
under foot_,” were so trodden down by _the Lacedæmonians_
in their advance. But this is in every way improbable. The
Lacedæmonians were particularly slow in their motions, regular
in their ranks, and backward as to pursuit, qualities which are
dwelt upon by Thucydidês in regard to this very battle. They were
not at all likely to overtake such terrified men as were only
anxious to run away: moreover, if they did overtake them, they
would spear them, not trample them under foot.
To be trampled under foot, though possible enough from the
numerous Persian cavalry (Herodot. vii, 173; Xenoph. Hellen.
iii, 4, 12), is not the treatment which defeated soldiers meet
with from victorious hostile infantry in the field, especially
Lacedæmonian infantry. But it is precisely the treatment which
they meet with, if they be in one of the hinder ranks, from their
own panic-stricken comrades in the front rank, who find the enemy
closing upon them, and rush back madly to get away from him. Of
course it was the Argeians in the front rank who were seized
with the most violent panic, and who thus fell back upon their
own comrades in the rear ranks, overthrowing and treading them
down to secure their own escape. It seems quite plain that it
was the Argeians in front—not the Lacedæmonians—who trod down
their comrades in the rear (there were probably six or eight
men in every file), in order to escape themselves before the
Lacedæmonians should be upon them: compare Xen. Hellenic. iv, 4,
11; Œconomic. viii, 5.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account