Pausanias (ix, 1, 3) places this capture of Platæa in the third
year (counting the years from midsummer to midsummer) before
the battle of Leuktra; or in the year of the archon Asteius at
Athens; which seems to me the true date, though Mr. Clinton
supposes it (without ground, I think) to be contradicted by
Xenophon. The year of the archon Asteius reaches from midsummer
373 to 372 B.C. It is in the latter half of the year that I
suppose Platæa to have been taken.
It was not merely with Platæa, but also with Thespiæ, that Thebes
was now meddling. Mistrusting the dispositions of the Thespians, she
constrained them to demolish the fortifications of their town;[340]
as she had caused to be done fifty-two years before, after the
victory of Delium,[341] on suspicion of leanings favorable to Athens.
[340] I infer this from Isokrates, Or. xiv, (Plataic.) s. 21-38;
compare also sect. 10. The Platæan speaker accuses the Thebans
of having destroyed the walls of some Bœotian cities (over and
above what they had done to Platæa,) and I venture to apply this
to Thespiæ. Xenophon indeed states that the Thespians were at
this very period treated exactly like the Platæans; that is,
driven out of Bœotia, and their town destroyed; except that they
had not the same claim on Athens (Hellen. vi, 3, 1—ἀπόλιδας
γενομένους: compare also vi, 3, 5). Diodorus also (xv, 46)
speaks of the Thebans as having destroyed Thespiæ. But against
this, I gather, from the Plataic Oration of Isokrates, that the
Thespians were not in the same plight with the Platæans when
that oration was delivered; that is, they were not expelled
collectively out of Bœotia. Moreover, Pausanias also expressly
says that the Thespians were present in Bœotia at the time of
the battle of Leuktra, and that they were expelled shortly
afterwards. Pausanias at the same time gives a distinct story,
about the conduct of the Thespians, which it would not be
reasonable to reject (ix, 13, 3; ix, 14, 1). I believe therefore
that Xenophon has spoken inaccurately in saying that the
Thespians were ἀπόλιδες _before_ the battle of Leuktra. It is
quite possible that they might have sent supplications to Athens
(ἱκετεύοντας—Xen. Hell. vi, 3, 1) in consequence of the severe
mandate to demolish their walls.
[341] Thucyd. iv, 133.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account