History of Spanish and Portuguese Literature (Vol 1 of 2)Bouterwek, Friedrich
History
History of Spanish and Portuguese Literature (Vol 1 of 2)
Bouterwek, Friedrich
Portuguese literature -- History and criticism; Spanish literature -- History and criticism
If it be admitted that there remains in English literature a vacant
place which ought to be occupied by a work of this kind, it is not
apprehended that the means now resorted to for filling up the chasm
will be disapproved; at least the translator is not aware that any
better source could have been found for supplying the deficiency. In
vain, she is persuaded, would any substitute be sought for in French,
much as that language abounds in works of criticism. Sismondi in his
_Litterature du Midi de l’Europe_, implicitly adopts the judgments
passed by Bouterwek on Spanish and Portuguese literature; and indeed
with respect to that part of his subject he says very little of
importance that is not directly borrowed from the German critic.[2]
The _Essai sur la Litterature Espagnole_, published in Paris in 1810,
and which appears to have been well received by the French public, is
a gross plagiarism. It is, with some slight additions, merely the
translation of an anonymous English work, entitled, _Letters from
an English Traveller in Spain_, the epistolary form being dropped,
and the materials transposed for the purpose of concealing the
theft.[3] The work of M. Bouterwek belongs, however, to a superior
class. To say that M. Bouterwek has treated his subject with great
perspicuity and precision, would be to express only a small portion of
his merits. Extensive and laborious as his enquiries have evidently
been, his judgment in the management of his materials is still more
remarkable than the indefatigable research with which they must have
been obtained. He has not confined himself to a mere narrative of the
progress and an exemplification of the beauties and deformities of
the literature of which he is the historian.--The philosophic spirit
which pervades his criticism was not to be circumscribed within such
narrow bounds. He seeks in the structure of society, the habits of the
people, and the influence of events, for the causes of the intellectual
phenomena he has to describe; and he examines with great candour and
impartiality the effects of mis-government and arbitrary institutions
on poetic genius and literary taste. Impressed with this favourable
opinion of the work, the translator has endeavoured to give a true
representation of its contents. In undertaking the translation, her
wish was to preserve the character of the original, as far as possible,
under an English dress. She began the task with an anticipation of its
difficulty, and she ends it with a consciousness of the indulgence of
which her labours stand in need; but at the same time with the hope
that she will not be found to have altogether failed in the object she
had in view.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account