History of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Volume 5Smith, Joseph, Jr.
History
History of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Volume 5
Smith, Joseph, Jr.
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints; Smith, Joseph, Jr., 1805-1844
It was maintained on the part of those who believed that the municipal
court had the right to issue writs of _habeas corpus_ against process
issued from the state courts that all the power there was in Illinois
she gave to Nauvoo, and that the municipal court had all the power
within the limits of the city that the state courts had, and that
power was given by the same authority--the legislature. A number of
lawyers of more or less prominence in the state professed to hold
these views; but little reliance can be put in the support they bring
to the case, since all of them were seeking political preferment,
immediately or remotely, and would and did in their interpretation of
the powers granted by the charter, favor that side of the controversy
most likely to please the citizens of Nauvoo. Governor Ford, too, at
the time, gave a tacit approval of the course taken by the municipal
court in issuing the writ of _habeas corpus_, though he afterwards
became very pronounced in his opposition to the exercise of such
powers. His acquiescence appears in this, that as soon as Joseph was
liberated, sheriff Reynolds applied to Governor Ford for a _posse_
to retake him, representing that the Prophet had been unlawfully
taken out of his hands by the municipal court of Nauvoo: whereupon
the governor refused to grant the petition. Subsequently the governor
of Missouri asked Governor Ford to call out the militia to retake
Joseph, but this he also refused to do, and gave as a reason that
"no process, officer, or authority of the state had been resisted or
interfered with;" and recited how the prisoner had been released on
_habeas corpus_ by the municipal court of Nauvoo. The governor acted
in this instance with perfect knowledge of what had taken place, for
the petition and statement of Reynolds were in his possession, as
were also complete copies of all the documents which contained the
proceedings before the municipal court of Nauvoo; and in addition to
these sources of information, the governor had dispatched a trusted
secret agent, a Mr. Brayman, to Nauvoo, who investigated the case and
reported the result to him. It must be held, however, both as a matter
of fact and of law, that the grant in the Nauvoo city charter was
intended by the legislature only to give power to the municipal court
to issue writs of _habeas corpus_ in cases of arrest for violation
of city ordinances; and that giving {XXVII} power to the municipal
court to test the warrants or processes issued from the state courts
was never contemplated by the legislature, and that the passage of
any ordinance by the city council that would bring about or authorize
any such unusual proceeding was an unwarranted assumption of power,
utterly wrong in principle and consequently subversive of government.
But whatever opinion may be entertained on the legal point under
consideration, there can be no question but what upon the broad
principles of justice the Prophet Joseph ought to have been set free.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account