History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present timeWhewell, William
History
History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present time
Whewell, William
Science -- History
perceive that, if they considered the weight of the body as a power
acting to produce motion, they must consider the body itself as
offering a resistance to motion; and that the effect must depend on
the proportion of the power to the resistance; in short, they had no
clear idea of _accelerating force_. This defect runs through all
their mechanical speculations, and renders them entirely valueless.
We may exemplify the same confusion of thought on mechanical
subjects in writers of a less technical character. Thus, if men had
any distinct idea of mechanical action, they could not have accepted
for a moment the fable of the Echineis or Remora, a little fish
which was said to be able to stop a large ship merely by sticking to
it.[1\4] Lucan refers to this legend in a poetical manner, and
notices this creature only in bringing together a collection of
monstrosities; but Pliny relates the tale gravely, and moralizes
upon it after his manner. "What," he cries,[2\4] "is more violent
than the sea and the winds? what a greater work of art than a ship?
Yet one little fish (the Echineis) can hold back all these when they
all strain the same way. The winds may {191} blow, the waves may
rage; but this small creature controls their fury, and stops a
vessel, when chains and anchors would not hold it: and this it does,
not by hard labor, but merely by adhering to it. Alas, for human
vanity! when the turreted ships which man has built, that he may
fight from castle-walls, at sea as well as at land, are held captive
and motionless by a fish a foot and a half long! Such a fish is said
to have stopped the admiral's ship at the battle of Actium, and
compelled Antony to go into another. And in our own memory, one of
these animals held fast the ship of Caius, the emperor, when he was
sailing from Astura to Antium. The stopping of this ship, when all
the rest of the fleet went on, caused surprise; but this did not
last long, for some of the men jumped into the water to look for the
fish, and found it sticking to the rudder; they showed it to Caius,
who was indignant that this animal should interpose its prohibition
to his progress, when impelled by four hundred rowers. It was like a
slug; and had no power, after it was taken into the ship."
[Note 1\4: Lucan is describing one of the poetical compounds
produced in incantations.
Huc quicquid fœtu genuit Natura sinistro
Miscetur: non spuma canum quibus unda timori est,
Viscera non lyncis, non duræ nodus hyænæ
Defuit, et cervi pasti serpente medullæ;
In mediis _Echineis_ aquis, oculique draconum.
Etc. _Pharsalia_, **vi. 670.]
[Note 2\4: Plin. _Hist. N._ xxxii. 5.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account