History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present timeWhewell, William
History
History of the inductive sciences, from the earliest to the present time
Whewell, William
Science -- History
Kepler joined Tycho Brahe at Prague in 1600, and found him and
Longomontanus busily employed in correcting the theory of Mars; and
he also then entered upon that train of researches which he
published in 1609 in his extraordinary work _On the Motions of
Mars_. In this work, as in others, he gives an account, not only of
his success, but of his failures, explaining, at length, the various
suppositions which he had made, the notions by which he had been led
to invent or to entertain them, the processes by which he had proved
their {298} falsehood, and the alternations of hope and sorrow, of
vexation and triumph, through which he had gone. It will not be
necessary for us to cite many passages of these kinds, curious and
amusing as they are.
One of the most important truths contained in the motions of Man is
the discovery that the plane of the orbit of the planet should be
considered with reference to the sun itself, instead of referring it
to any of the other centres of motion which the eccentric hypothesis
introduced: and that, when so considered, it had none of the
librations which Ptolemy and Copernicus had attributed to it. The
fourteenth chapter of the second part asserts, "Plana eccentricorum
esse ἀτάλαντα;" that the planes are _unlibrating_; retaining always
the same inclination to the ecliptic, and the same _line of nodes_.
With this step Kepler appears to have been justly delighted.
"Copernicus," he says, "not knowing the value of what he possessed
(his system), undertook to represent Ptolemy, rather than nature, to
which, however, he had approached more nearly than any other person.
For being rejoiced that the quantity of the latitude of each planet
was increased by the approach of the earth to the planet, according to
his theory, he did not venture to reject the rest of Ptolemy's
increase of latitude, but in order to express it, devised librations
of the planes of the eccentric, depending not upon its own eccentric,
but (most improbably) upon the orbit of the earth, which has nothing
to do with it. I always fought against this impertinent tying together
of two orbits, even before I saw the observations of Tycho; and I
therefore rejoice much that in this, as in others of my preconceived
opinions, the observations were found to be on my side." Kepler
established his point by a fair and laborious calculation of the
results of observations of Mars made by himself and Tycho Brahe; and
had a right to exult when the result of these calculations confirmed
his views of the symmetry and simplicity of nature.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account