History of the Origin of Representative Government in EuropeGuizot, François
History
History of the Origin of Representative Government in Europe
Guizot, François
Europe -- History; Representative government and representation
The _Almocadene_ or captain of foot soldiers, the
_Alfaqueque_ or officer employed to treat for the ransom of
captives from the Moors, and the _Comitre_ or captain of a
ship, were appointed in a similar manner, and by the
recommendation of a jury composed, not of members of the class to
which the candidate belonged, but to members of the class to
which he aspired. This circumstance alone settles the question;
for it is a result of chivalric, and not of Barbarian manners; it
reminds us of the squire who was dubbed knight by knights, and
not of the warrior who was chosen or judged by his peers.
I shall not follow the author in his researches on ordeal by
boiling water and by fire, or upon trial by combat. Although we
meet with traces of these customs in the old monuments of some
Barbarian legislations, they were not the common law of modern
peoples, during the first epoch of their establishment on the
Roman territory. It was at a later period, and by the influence
either of the corruption of religious ideas by superstition, or
of the military organization of the feudal system, that they
became developed, recognized, and formed into a veritable
jurisprudence. The general facts of Europe do not, therefore,
authorize us to conclude that, because they existed among the
Spaniards in the fourteenth century, they also existed among the
Visigoths in the seventh century. The almost absolute silence of
the historic monuments of the first epoch, here retains all its
authority.
{250}
Compurgation.
The facts relative to compurgation, by the oath of a certain
number of witnesses, are more important and more curious.
"Compurgation," says our author, "is directed in express terms in
all the Teutonic laws; but it does not appear to have been
admissible in trials conducted according to the forms prescribed
by the _Fuero juzgo_. Yet afterwards, this ordeal was widely
spread as a _fuero_, both in civil and criminal trials.
Though discountenanced by the legislature, it was retained in
practice; and a forcible illustration is thus given of the
stubbornness with which the Goths adhered to their usages and
customs. _Trial by jury_, through it, in its germ was felt
to be a benefit."
"As an ancient and general usage of Castile, the trial is
sanctioned in the _Fuero Viejo_. As a local custom or
bye-law of the cities of Castile and Leon and their dependencies,
it was very frequently established, or rather _declared_, by
the charters granted by their founders.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account