History of the pianoforte and pianoforte playersBie, Oskar
History
History of the pianoforte and pianoforte players
Bie, Oskar
Pianists; Piano -- History
The tendency of the public, to group celebrities in pairs, has
brought not merely Goethe and Schiller, but Bach and Handel, into
juxtaposition. How little the scholarly hermit had in common with the
grandiose world-musician--who first followed the wise prescription,
glory in Italy, gain in England--would be seen from a comparison of
their clavier-writings, which are a fair average of their general
work. Handel is the negation of the classic. He gets his results
from materials close at hand; brings them into plastic clearness,
and writes from the point of view of the vulgar herd; he is never
troubled by an exacting inward conception, or overwhelmed by his own
imagination, as are all true classic artists.[101]
Handel’s clavier-pieces are written in an extravagantly popular
style. His suites, which moreover embrace not dance-forms only; his
capriccios, variations and fantasias, flow like futile “water-music.”
They are brilliant without being difficult, and entertaining
without being suggestive. There is no colour on the sky of their
landscapes; no tempest lashes their trees. We roll in our coaches
on well-macadamised roads, the melody of the wheels reminding us
meanwhile of this or that well-worn turn in the operas or oratorios.
Seldom is a halt necessary in order to look at the view. Perhaps
we may stop a moment longer than usual at those frequent singing
sarabands in the popular style, at the charming salon-gigues
(especially the long one in G minor), the genuine virtuoso’s
Tarantella, or at the better F sharp minor suite with its short
free prelude, staccato largo, insinuating fugue and dramatic gigue.
Perhaps, also, the fugue with its _three beats_ from the E minor
Prelude may please us; but there is a something which the whole fails
to give us. It is an acquaintance--not a personal intimacy.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account