History of the war in the Peninsula and in the south of France from the year 1807 to the year 1814, vol. 3 — John Shaqi
History of the war in the Peninsula and in the south of France from the year 1807 to the year 1814, vol. 3Napier, William Francis Patrick
History
History of the war in the Peninsula and in the south of France from the year 1807 to the year 1814, vol. 3
Napier, William Francis Patrick
Peninsular War, 1807-1814
Regular armies have seldom failed to produce great men, and one
great man is sufficient to save a nation: but when every person is
permitted to make war in the manner most agreeable to himself;--for
one that comes forward with patriotic intentions, there will be two
to act from personal interest; in short, there will be more robbers
than generals. One of the first exploits of Espoz y Mina was to
slay the commander of a neighbouring band, because, under the mask
of patriotism, he was plundering his own countrymen: nay, this the
most fortunate of all the chiefs, would never suffer any other
Partida than his own to be in his district; he also, as I have before
related, made a species of commercial treaty with the French, and
strove earnestly and successfully to raise his band to the dignity
of a regular force. Nor was this manner of considering the guerilla
system confined to the one side. The following observations of St.
Cyr, a man of acknowledged talents, show that, after considerable
experience of this mode of warfare, he also felt that the evil was
greater than the benefit.
“Far from casting general blame on the efforts made by the Catalans,
I admired them; but, as they often exceeded the bounds of reason,
their heroism was detrimental to their cause. Many times it caused
the destruction of whole populations without necessity and without
advantage.”
“When a country is invaded by an army stronger than that which
defends it, it is beyond question that the population should come
to the assistance of the troops, and lend them every support; but,
without an absolute necessity, the former should not be brought on
to the field of battle.”--“It is inhuman to place their inexperience
in opposition to hardened veterans.”
“Instead of _exasperating_ the people of Catalonia, the leaders
should have endeavoured to _calm_ them, and have directed their
ardour so as to second the army on great occasions. But they excited
them without cessation, led them day after day into fire, fatigued
them, harassed them, forced them to abandon their habitations, to
embark if they were on the coast, if inland to take to the mountains
and perish of misery within sight of their own homes, thus abandoned
to the mercy of a hungry and exasperated soldiery. The people’s
ardour was exhausted daily in partial operations, and hence, on great
occasions, when they could have been eminently useful, they were not
to be had.”
“Their good will had been so often abused by the folly of their
leaders, that many times their assistance was called for in vain.
The peasantry, of whom so much had been demanded, began to demand in
their turn. They insisted that the soldiers should fight always to
the last gasp, were angry when the latter retreated, and robbed and
ill-used them when broken by defeat.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account