History of Zionism, 1600-1918, Vol. 2 (of 2)Sokolow, Nahum
History
History of Zionism, 1600-1918, Vol. 2 (of 2)
Sokolow, Nahum
Jews -- Restoration; Zionism -- History
The meeting was most successful. There never had been such a Zionist
triumph in Hull. The enthusiasm was shared by both the Christian
representatives and the Jewish population, the latter but recently
arrived for the most part from Eastern Europe. There was only one
discordant note in the speeches, and that probably escaped the notice
of most of those present, and did not detract in the least from the
success of the meeting; this was an utterance that offended Sir Mark’s
religious sentiment. “It is natural,” someone said, “for Sir Mark to
be a friend of the Jews as he is such a good Christian, and must be
conscious of the fact that the founder of Christianity belonged to the
Jewish race; moreover, Sir Mark as a Catholic venerates the Holy Mother
who was as we know a daughter of the Jewish people.” This utterance
pained Sir Mark and hurt me very much. I afterwards had long talks with
Sir Mark about this tactlessness, which could only have been committed
by a quasi-assimilated Jew. The speaker may have meant it well, but
a Zionist could never have made such a mistake, for to be a Zionist,
means not only to desire immediate emigration to Palestine, but also
to maintain the proper practical attitude to the non-Jewish world. This
attitude is one neither of servility nor of arrogance, it is one of
dignified yet modest and noble self-consciousness, self-respect and
respect for others.
In order to understand the attitude of such as Sir Mark and others
like him in his own and other nations, towards the Jewish problem,
it is necessary to study the problem more closely than is common
among the unthinking crowd who bandy about the words anti-Semitism and
philo-Semitism, and, upon their superficial observations, condemn one
man as an anti-Semite and laud another as a philo-Semite, according as
whether they hate or love certain individual Jews. The crowd does not
understand that one can be a great friend of the Jewish people and a
great admirer of the Jewish genius and yet find such things ridiculous
and repulsive as the apeing, the servility, the obtrusiveness, the
hollowness and the empty display, the desire to intrude everywhere,
the excessive zeal of the neophytes and all the unpleasant traits of
some assimilated Jews. On the other hand, one may approve of all these
qualities and rejoice that certain Jews have become rich, obtained
titles or gained high office in so far as one desires the assimilation
of the Jewish people and the extinction of the Jewish spirit.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account