Household Words, No. 11, June 8, 1850 : $b A weekly journal
General
Household Words, No. 11, June 8, 1850 : $b A weekly journal
English literature -- Periodicals
What happens at Pentonville, and what takes place at Millbank, is done
under the same eye, under the same legislative supervision. The two
“great experiments” of iron and feather-bed prison reform are worked out
by the same power. The despots of Russia, Austria, and China, are at
least consistent. They have not carried on opposite systems—one of
extreme severity, and another of superlative ‘coddling.’ In no other
country but this does Justice—blind as she is—administer cocoa and
condign misery to the same degree of crime with the same hand.
We have thrown these facts together, merely to awaken attention to them.
We purposely abstain from suggestive comment. We know that the subject
of reformatory punishment is fraught with difficulties, to conquer which
all the “great experiments” have been tried. But they have only been
“great” because of their great expense and their great failure; and when
the failure is incontestable—proved beyond doubt by the direst
results,—should they not be abandoned, and something else tried, instead
of being made an absolute matter of faith, and a test to which certain
county magistrates, whom we could name, bring every man who is unhappy
enough to be within their power? The cause of it is plainly and
constantly presented at the bar of every Police Court and in the dock of
every Sessions House. It has resulted from an utter misapprehension of
means to end, and a lofty disregard of the good old adage, “prevention
is better than cure.” Although it has been daily observed that
ignorance—moral more than intellectual—ignorance has been the forerunner
of all juvenile crime, we have never tried any very great experiment
upon _that_. On the contrary, we spend hundreds of thousands every year
to effect the manifest impossibility of re-forming what has never been
formed. We have tried every shade of system but the right. Ingenuity has
been on the rack to invent every sort of reformatory, from the iron rule
of Millbank, to the affectionate fattening at Pentonville—except one,
and that happens to be the right one. Punishment has occupied all our
thoughts,—training, none. We condemn young criminals for not knowing
certain moralities which we have not taught them, and—by herding them
with accomplished professors of dishonesty in transit jails—punish them
for immoralities which have been there taught them. Instances of this
can be adduced in so large a proportion as to amount to a rule; to which
the appearance of instructed juvenile criminals at the tribunals is the
exception. Two or three glaring cases occurred only the past month. We
select one as reported in the “Globe” newspaper of Tuesday, May 7:—
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account