Though it has been represented by the steeple-chase riders as a most
enormous heresy to contemplate the possibility of any prisoner going mad
or idiotic, under the prolonged effects of separate confinement; and
although any one who should have the temerity to maintain such a doubt
in Pennsylvania, would have a chance of becoming a profane St. Stephen;
Lord Grey, in his very last speech in the House of Lords on this
subject, made in the present session of Parliament, in praise of this
separate system, said of it: ‘Wherever it has been fairly tried, one of
its great defects has been discovered to be this,—that it cannot be
continued for a sufficient length of time without danger to the
individual, and that human nature cannot bear it beyond a limited
period. The evidence of medical authorities proves beyond dispute that,
if it is protracted beyond twelve months, the health of the convict,
mental and physical, would require the most close and vigilant
superintendence. Eighteen months is stated to be the _maximum_ time for
the continuance of its infliction, and, as a general rule, it is advised
that it never be continued for more than twelve months.’ This being
conceded, and it being clear that the prisoner’s mind, and all the
apprehensions weighing upon it, must be influenced from the first hour
of his imprisonment by the greater or less extent of its duration in
perspective before him, we are content to regard the system as
dissociated in England from the American objection of too great
severity.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account