There is no reasonable debate as to the passage of one species to
another. It is clearly manifested in the succession of fauna found
today all over the world in the sedimentary rocks. Even the most casual
student of paleontology is convinced of this glaring truth. “The brutal
cogency of a slab of fossils could be hated and fought, but could not
be gainsaid.” But when we are confronted with the question of setting
a standard of measuring geologic time by means of this paleontological
record, more precisely, through this biological process, we cannot
help pondering over the grave uncertainty of the result. When we fix
our gaze upon a trilobite, a three-lobed, crab-like creature (Pl. II
fig. 1) that ruled the seas in the dim days of the Cambrian period (p.
11) and see that it was equipped with gills and swimming organs, with
powers of digestion and excretion, with specific organs of circulation
and reproduction and with motor and sensory nerves, and compare it
with one of its tribe, a present day horseshoe crab, (Pl. II fig. 2)
we do not find any noticeable progress in structure, in intricacy or
in the degree of specialization. Yet the time that has elapsed since
the Cambrian is, according to a moderate estimate, nearly 600,000,000
years! (p. 11). Geologic record testifies that evolution awaits
environmental change, that animals in some way adjust themselves to
their environment, either by discarding or modifying old characters or
by acquiring new ones. Yet, what are known as “immortal” types, such as
the brachiopods, Lingula, Crania and Terebratula (Pl. III figs. 1-3)
or the pelecypods, such as Pecten, Pinna and Arca (Pl. III figs. 4-6)
or the gastropods, such as Pleurotomaria, Natica and Trochus (Pl. III
figs. 7-9), have withstood all possible environmental changes and have
steadfastly held their own ever since we have records of their very
early appearance on earth. On the contrary, we have records of types
that have yielded so rapidly to change that their evolution is almost
explosive. It is almost incomprehensible how, within such a limited
period of time, fishes have changed into amphibians, amphibians into
reptiles, and reptiles into birds and mammals (Pl. IV figs. 1-4). With
these conflicting evidences staring us in the face, with the knowledge
that the entire organic world has been subject to earth-wide periods
of long stagnation and rapid intensive change, one may well ponder
whether it is within our power to establish a standard for measuring
geologic time on the evidence of life transformation. The study of the
succession of faunas—the change of one species to another, can only
indicate the magnitude of time involved. It cannot afford any basis,
whatsoever, for a concrete expression of geologic time.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account