How Old Is It? The Story of Dating in ArcheaologySchoenwetter, James
Science
How Old Is It? The Story of Dating in Archeaology
Schoenwetter, James
Archaeological dating; Dendrochronology; Radiocarbon dating
The C-14 dating technique measures time by radioactive decomposition of
materials. There are other clocks which depend on the chemical
decomposition of materials. The forgery of the Piltdown Man fossil was
detected by a dating method which depends on the decomposition of bone
protein and its replacement by fluorine. Fluorine is an element which
occurs naturally as a gas, but which combines readily with other
elements to form compounds. Some of these elements are common in bones.
Since fluorine is one of nature’s most reactive elements, it tends to
escape from the compound it is in and to form other compounds. As the
protein in a bone decays, it is often replaced by fluorine. The amount
of fluorine in old bones, then, is expected to be more than in young
bones since it has had more time to accumulate. Since fluorine does not
accumulate at a constant rate, it affords only a relative measure of
age.
In the case of Piltdown, a group of bones was discovered at a site, and
was said to contain those of one individual who lived about 60,000 years
ago. Almost 100 years after they were discovered, these bones were put
to the fluorine test. It was found that (1) some of the bones had less
fluorine than others, so not all were of the same antiquity and could
not have belonged to the same individual, (2) the younger bones had as
much fluorine in them as modern bones, and (3) the older bones had more
fluorine in them than bones known to be 60,000 years old.
[Illustration: (uncaptioned)]
Another form of absolute dating of importance to archaeology is that
called the _varve_ method. This can only be utilized as an absolute
clock under very special circumstances however. Varves are like tree
rings in a way. In a lake which is sufficiently deep, or at the edge of
a glacier, particles of sediment are being deposited continuously as a
sort of fallout from the water. During the winter, when the glacier
freezes or the density of the water in the lake increases because of the
cooler temperature, less particles are deposited, and those which are
deposited are usually of a characteristic color or texture. During the
summer, when the glacier melts or the lake warms up, more and different
particles are deposited. The bands of deposited sediment are called
varves; every year two varves are formed. Starting from the top, one can
count back the number of years in a varve series. If the top varve is of
known date such as the present year, one has a calendar with each varve
having a known date. Attempts are made to correlate one varve series
with another in order to recover even longer series. If the
archaeologist is lucky, and it is not rare in Europe, there will be
materials from a site buried in the local varve sequence. Counting back
gives an absolute age for the artifacts embedded in the site and thus an
approximate age for the site. The European varve chronology is believed
to extend back to about 9650 B.C.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account