How to Select Cows: or, The Guenon system simplified, explained, and practically appliedHazard, Willis P. (Willis Pope)
Science
How to Select Cows: or, The Guenon system simplified, explained, and practically applied
Hazard, Willis P. (Willis Pope)
Cattle -- Judging; Cows; Dairy cattle
recommend him to the favorable notice of that magistrate, who is ever
disposed to promote all that tends to improve it.”
From 1822 to 1827, it would seem that Guenon perfected and studied his
system, but it does not seem to have come promptly before the public,
until the agricultural society of Bordeaux took upon itself a careful
investigation of the whole system. From the detailed report of this
committee, appointed by this society to test the knowledge of Guenon, we
take the following as illustrating, not only the results reached by them,
but also the manner of conducting the examination:
“Every cow subjected to examination was separated from the
rest. What Mr. Guenon had to say in regard to her was taken
down in writing by one of the committee; and immediately after,
the proprietor, who had kept at a distance, was interrogated,
and such questions put to him as would tend to confirm or
disprove the judgment pronounced by Mr. Guenon. In this way we
have examined, in a most careful manner—note being taken of
every fact and every observation made by any one present—upward
of sixty cows and heifers, and we are bound to declare that
every statement made by Mr. Guenon, with respect to each of
them, whether it regarded the quantity of milk, or the time
during which the cow continued to give milk after being got
with calf, or finally, the quality of the milk as being more
or less creamy or serous, were confirmed, and its accuracy
established. The only discrepancies which occurred, were
some slight differences in regard to the _quantity_ of milk,
but these we afterward fully satisfied ourselves were caused
entirely by the food of the animal being more or less abundant.
“The result of this first test seems conclusive, but they
acquire new force from those of a second trial in which the
method was subjected to another test through M. Guenon and his
brother. Your committee, availing themselves of the presence
of the latter, caused the same cows to be examined by the
two brothers, but separately, so that after a cow had been
inspected, and her qualities as indicated by the signs in
question had been pronounced upon by one of the brothers, he
was made to withdraw; then the other brother, who had been
kept aloof, was called up, and desired to state the qualities
of the same animal. This mode of proceeding could not fail
to give rise to difference, to contradiction even, between
the judgments of the two brothers, unless their method was a
positive and sure one. Well, gentlemen, we must say it, this
last test was absolutely decisive. Not only did the judgment
of the two brothers accord perfectly together, but they were
in perfect accordance also with all that was said by the
proprietors in regard to the qualities, good or bad, of every
animal subject to this examination.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account