We all remember the shameful tale (told, not by Mr. Burdett-Coutts
alone, but by eminent doctors, including Sir Frederick Treves, whose
words were published in Blue-books) of the utter disorganization and
incompetence of the medical and surgical departments attached to the
British army in South Africa.
Sir Frederick Treves has inspected the Japanese hospitals for the
wounded, and pronounced them to be perfect.
The Japanese, your wiseacre retorts, are a race of clever imitators.
We invent; they borrow. They can copy but they cannot produce
masterpieces in the arts and sciences. It is good rhetoric but bad
reasoning. The Japanese have borrowed from us neither their art, nor
their ethics. Never conquered in the past, they have developed a
civilization peculiarly their own. The first Mikado was reigning six
centuries before Julius Cæsar landed his legions at a point not five
miles from the spot where I am writing. The Japanese are an ancient
race with points of view diametrically opposed to our own; and like
the Jews they have lived long and learned wisdom.
“If I say anything about Shakespeare,” writes Baron Suyematsu,
“I fear I should at once be considered to be overstepping
propriety; but I must say that even Shakespeare’s plays, some
of which I have read or seen performed, have never given me
such impressions as do the plays of Japan. Whenever we go to
the Western stages we appreciate the decorations, we admire the
splendid movements and good figures of the actors and
actresses, and, so far as we can understand it, the striking
elegance and powerful delivery of their dialogue, and we enjoy
ourselves as much as could be hoped; but on coming home we find
nothing left on our minds which might serve as an incentive in
our future career. No inspiration, no emulation! Such, then,
seems to be the difference between our dramatic works and those
of Western nations.”
Observe that the argument of “art for art’s sake,” is treated by the
talented Japanese diplomatist with the very sanest scorn.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account