Ideas of Good and EvilYeats, W. B. (William Butler)
Philosophy
Ideas of Good and Evil
Yeats, W. B. (William Butler)
Essays
To cover the imperishable lineaments of beauty with shadows and reflected
lights was to fall into the power of his 'Vala,' the indolent fascination
of nature, the woman divinity who is so often described in 'the prophetic
books' as 'sweet pestilence,' and whose children weave webs to take the
souls of men; but there was yet a more lamentable chance, for nature has
also a 'masculine portion' or 'spectre' which kills instead of merely
hiding, and is continually at war with inspiration. To 'generalize' forms
and shadows, to 'smooth out' spaces and lines in obedience to 'laws of
composition,' and of painting; founded, not upon imagination, which
always thirsts for variety and delights in freedom, but upon reasoning
from sensation which is always seeking to reduce everything to a lifeless
and slavish uniformity; as the popular art of Blake's day had done, and as
he understood Sir Joshua Reynolds to advise, was to fall into 'Entuthon
Benithon,' or 'the Lake of Udan Adan,' or some other of those regions
where the imagination and the flesh are alike dead, that he names by so
many resonant phantastical names. 'General knowledge is remote knowledge,'
he wrote; 'it is in particulars that wisdom consists, and happiness too.
Both in art and life general masses are as much art as a pasteboard man is
human. Every man has eyes, nose and mouth; this every idiot knows. But he
who enters into and discriminates most minutely the manners and
intentions, the characters in all their branches, is the alone wise or
sensible man, and on this discrimination all art is founded.... As poetry
admits not a letter that is insignificant, so painting admits not a grain
of sand or a blade of grass insignificant, much less an insignificant blot
or blur.'
Against another desire of his time, derivative also from what he has
called 'corporeal reason,' the desire for a 'tepid moderation,' for a
lifeless 'sanity in both art and life,' he had protested years before with
a paradoxical violence. 'The roadway of excess leads to the palace of
wisdom,' and we must only 'bring out weight and measure in time of
dearth.' This protest, carried, in the notes on Sir Joshua Reynolds, to
the point of dwelling with pleasure on the thought that 'The _Lives of the
Painters_ say that Raphael died of dissipation,' because dissipation is
better than emotional penury, seemed as important to his old age as to his
youth. He taught it to his disciples, and one finds it in its purely
artistic shape in a diary written by Samuel Palmer, in 1824: 'Excess is
the essential vivifying spirit, vital spark, embalming spice of the finest
art. There are many mediums in the _means_--none, oh, not a jot, not a
shadow of a jot, in the _end_ of great art. In a picture whose merit is to
be excessively brilliant, it can't be too brilliant, but individual tints
may be too brilliant.... We must not begin with medium, but think always
on excess and only use medium to make excess more abundantly excessive.'
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account