Illustrations of political economy, Volume 3 (of 9)Martineau, Harriet
General
Illustrations of political economy, Volume 3 (of 9)
Martineau, Harriet
Didactic fiction, English; Political fiction, English; Social problems -- Fiction
Mr. Nugent, the visitor, met Miss Burke with an observation on the
improvement of workhouses which rendered them accessible to female
benevolence; whereas they were once places where no lady could set her
foot. Miss Burke gravely replied that there was much yet for benevolence
to do. The necessary evils of a workhouse were bad enough; and it was
afflicting to see them needlessly aggravated,—to see poverty and
indigence confounded, and blameless and culpable indigence, temporary
distress, and permanent destitution, all mixed up together, and placed
under the same treatment. These distinctions were somewhat too nice for
the gentleman’s perceptions; at least, while announced in abstract
terms. He stood in an attitude of perplexed attention, while Wilkes
asked whether she would have the paupers live in separate dwellings.
Miss Burke observed that the evil began out of the workhouse; and that
the want of proper distinctions there made classification in the house
an imperative duty.
“We are too apt,” she said, “to regard all the poor alike, and to speak
of them as one class, whether or not they are dependent; that is,
whether they are indigent or only poor. There must always be poor in
every society; that is, persons who can live by their industry, but have
nothing beforehand. But that there should be able-bodied indigent, that
is, capable persons who cannot support themselves, is a disgrace to
every society, and ought to be so far regarded as such as to make us
very careful how we confound the poor and the indigent.”
“I assure you, ma’am,” said Wilkes, “it grieves me very much to see
honest working men, or sober servants out of place, come here to be
mixed up with rogues and vagabonds.”
“But they are all indigent alike,” observed Mr. Nugent, “or your honest
labourers would not have to come here.”
“All indigent, certainly, sir; but not all alike. We have had cottagers
here for a time, after losing cows and pigs by accident; and even little
farmers after a fire on their premises; and labourers, when many
hundreds were turned off at once from the public works. Now, this sort
of indigence is very different from that which springs out of vice.”
“It seems to me,” said Miss Burke, “that as wide a distinction ought to
be made between temporary and lasting indigence, and between innocent
and guilty indigence, within the workhouse, as between poverty and
indigence out of it; and as the numbers are, I believe, very unequal, I
should think it might easily be done. I suppose, Mr. Wilkes, those who
require permanent support, the invalids and the thoroughly depraved, are
few in comparison with those who come in and go out again after a time.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account