Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the EarthPlayfair, John
Science
Illustrations of the Huttonian Theory of the Earth
Playfair, John
Geology; Hutton, James, 1726-1797. Theory of the earth
13. Again, if water was the solvent by which the consolidating matter
was introduced into the interstices of the strata, that matter could
consist only of such substances as are soluble in water, whereas
it consists of a vast variety of substances, altogether insoluble
either in it, or in any single menstruum whatsoever. The strata are
consolidated, for example, by quartz, by fluor, by feldspar, and by all
the metals, in their endless combinations with sulphureous bodies. To
affirm that water was ever capable of dissolving these substances, is
to ascribe to it powers which it confessedly has not at present; and,
therefore, it is to introduce an hypothesis, not merely gratuitous, but
one which, physically speaking, is absurd and impossible.
This is not all, however; for, even if this difficulty were to be
passed over, it would still be required to explain, how the water,
which, together with the matter which it held in solution, had
insinuated itself into the pores of the strata, became suddenly
disposed to deposit that matter, and to allow it, by crystallization
or concretion, to assume a solid form.[7] The Neptunists must either
assign a sufficient reason for this great and universal change, or must
expect to see their system treated as an inartificial accumulation
of hypotheses which assigns opposite virtues to the same subject,
and is alike at variance with nature and with itself; in a word, a
system that might pass for the invention of an age, when as yet sound
philosophy had not alighted on the earth, nor taught man that he is
but the minister and interpreter of nature, and can neither extend his
power nor his knowledge a hair's-breadth beyond his experience and
observation of the present order of things.[8]
[Footnote 7: NOTE VI.]
[Footnote 8: Homo naturæ minister, et interpres tantùm facit et
intelligit, quantùm de naturæ ordine re, vel mente, observaverit: nec
amplius scit, aut potest.--Nov. Org. lib. i. aph. 1.]
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account