I should say that the imitation was quite within the bounds of good
taste. The bad taste is in the wish to imitate Europe at all; but with
the abundance of money, the imitation is simply inevitable. There
is no American life for wealth; there is no native formula for the
expression of social superiority; because America means equality if it
means anything, in the last analysis. But in all this show on the Park
driveways, you get no effect so vivid as the effect of sterility in
that liberty without equality which seems to satisfy us Americans. A
man may come into the Park with any sort of vehicle, so that it is not
for the carriage of merchandise, and he is free to spoil what might
be a fine effect with the intrusion of whatever squalor of turnout
he will. He has as much right there as any one, but the right to be
shabby in the presence of people who are fine is not one that I should
envy him. I do not think that he can be comfortable in it, for the
superiority around him puts him to shame, as it puts the poor man to
shame at every turn in life, though some people, with an impudence
that is pitiable, will tell you that it does not put him to shame;
that he feels himself as good as any one. We are always talking about
human nature and what it is, and what it is not; but we try in our
blind worship of inequality to refuse the first and simplest knowledge
of human nature, which testifies of itself in every throb of our own
hearts, as we try even to refuse a knowledge of the Divine nature,
and attribute to the Father of all a design in the injustice we have
ourselves created.
To me the lesson of Central Park is that where it is used in the spirit
of fraternity and equality, the pleasure in it is pure and fine, and
that its frequenters have for the moment a hint of the beauty which
might be perpetually in their lives; but where it is invaded by the
motives of the strife that raves all round it in the city outside, its
joys are fouled with contempt and envy, the worst passions that tear
the human heart. Ninety-nine Americans out of a hundred, have never
seen a man in livery; they have never dreamed of such a display as
this in the Park. Yet with our conditions, I fear that at sight of it
ninety-nine Americans out of every hundred would lust for their turn
of the wheel, their throw of the dice, so that they might succeed to a
place in it, and flaunt their luxury in the face of poverty, and abash
humility with their pride.
NEW YORK STREETS.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account