A traveller, small and insignificant, armed only with an oak cudgel,
was passing alone through a South American forest. As he trudged
forward he noticed at a certain point in the path (shall we call it
1894–1899?) that a jaguar was watching him and was about to break his
truce with man. He turned off to the right and there he saw a puma
and this too seemed to meditate evil. He hastened forward just in
time as his two enemies sprang at him, and these two near relatives
were locked in mortal grip--and so he passed on safe!
The reader, naturalist or layman, can point the moral for himself.
At the battle of Trafalgar, while fighting was in full progress on
one of the ships, some sailors were occupied in throwing overboard
the bodies of those who had been killed. A poor Scotchman badly
wounded and hardly conscious was taken up by two seamen, an
Englishman and an Irishman, and as they were about to throw him
overboard his feeble voice was heard to say “I’m no deed yet.”
“What’s that?” said the Irishman. “I’m no deed yet”; “Arrah, the
doctor said he was dead, over wid him,” said the Irishman.
Weismann.
During the period 1894–1899 there was a dramatic proclamation on the
part of one of the greatest living biologists, which was, in the cosmos
of biology, what the Proclamation of the Empress-Queen of India was in
1876, and it is not out of place to remind the reader that the fates
of the two Imperial utterances have been somewhat different. In 1895
Weismann issued his official statement of doctrine which was to crown
the work of his life, an essay on Germinal Selection. From Freyburg
in November, 1895, he wrote a preface to his address delivered on
September 16th in that year to the International Congress of Zoologists
at Leyden. This formed an epoch in biological thought and there lived
none so well qualified as Weismann to stand forth as its interpreter.
The well-translated, forcible language, and lucid thought leave the
reader in no manner of doubt as to his meaning. It took a wider form
in his final book on the Evolution Theory, but the germinal and
essential thoughts of the latter were contained in the former. From
1895 onwards the praise of Weismann was in all the churches. Probably
no modern worker in the fields of heredity and evolution has done so
much as Weismann towards raising great issues and removing some ancient
misconceptions; but it is one thing to raise great issues and another
to solve them. In this he has signally failed, nevertheless biological
theory would be the poorer if he had not made the attempt. Reflection,
the work of other biologists, and the remorseless hand of time have
shaken the edifices then raised. I will here only bring forward a few
of the most illuminating passages of the 1895 essay, and then refer to
the handling of Weismann’s work by Romanes.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account