Cartoons are meant for the man in the street; they are meant to tell
a story, to convey some feeling or idea rather than to be an artistic
rendering of an object or collection of objects. Therefore artistic
canons apply to them in this limited sense—that while the great
cartoonist may and must be as big an artist as he can, he must first
of all remember that he has to explain himself and his subjects, or
he ceases to be a cartoonist at all. A Futurist Forain, a Cubist
Raemaekers, are inconceivable because they would be quite useless as
cartoonists, whatever they were as artists.
The artistic value of the cartoons issued in all countries—and in
some cases it is very great—is a matter for future discussion. It is
of no present importance. What is of some actual value is a comparison
between the cartoons of the various countries, for they show with
unfailing accuracy the trend of public opinion. From the human point of
view this comparison is invaluable to the student of humanity in the
present upheaval. From the cheap postcard to the twopenny broadsheet,
from the most commonplace poster to the finest lithograph, each has
its place. To collect these things is not only very interesting, but
most enlightening; the national spirit and the national moods of each
country are unmistakably portrayed, and the crudest production takes
rank with the best as a human document.
III.
THE GOOD cause has always produced the good cartoonist—witness the
Napoleonic wars, when England rejoiced in Gillray and Rowlandson, while
France had no topical draughtsman of any outstanding merit. So far
as one can tell, this is very much the case with the present war. At
any rate, the good cause has produced its good men, and, judging by
what one can manage to see of German caricature, they have no mind of
any large calibre at work on cartoons. This is, perhaps, because the
greater part of the German drawings I have seen are intended to rouse
hatred, scorn, and anger. Clever they certainly are, but too many of
them are spiritually debased. The best are those directed against
England, which are dedicated to hatred, a passion greater than scorn or
anger, and consequently more elevating in its effects. Otherwise the
German cartoonist has not distinguished himself, in the sense that the
war has not raised him above himself.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account