Introduction to Mathematical Philosophy — John Shaqi
Introduction to Mathematical PhilosophyRussell, Bertrand
Philosophy
Introduction to Mathematical Philosophy
Russell, Bertrand
Mathematics -- Philosophy
From the point of view of the classification of relations, being
asymmetrical is a much more important characteristic than
implying diversity. Asymmetrical relations imply diversity,
but the converse is not the case. "Unequal," for example,
implies diversity, but is symmetrical. Broadly speaking, we
may say that, if we wished as far as possible to dispense with
relational propositions and replace them by such as ascribed
predicates to subjects, we could succeed in this so long as we
confined ourselves to symmetrical relations: those that do not
imply diversity, if they are transitive, may be regarded as asserting
a common predicate, while those that do imply diversity
may be regarded as asserting incompatible predicates. For
example, consider the relation of similarity between classes,
by means of which we defined numbers. This relation is symmetrical
and transitive and does not imply diversity. It would
be possible, though less simple than the procedure we adopted,
to regard the number of a collection as a predicate of the collection:
then two similar classes will be two that have the same
numerical predicate, while two that are not similar will be two
that have different numerical predicates. Such a method of
replacing relations by predicates is formally possible (though
often very inconvenient) so long as the relations concerned are
symmetrical; but it is formally impossible when the relations
are asymmetrical, because both sameness and difference of predicates
are symmetrical. Asymmetrical relations are, we may
[Pg 44]
say, the most characteristically relational of relations, and the
most important to the philosopher who wishes to study the
ultimate logical nature of relations.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account