Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
It is not merely that England ought not to rule Ireland but that
England cannot. It is not merely that Englishmen cannot rule Irishmen,
but that merchants cannot rule peasants. It is not so much that we have
dealt benefits to England and blows to Ireland. It is that our benefits
for England would be blows to Ireland. And this we already began to
admit in practice, before we had even dimly begun to conceive it in
theory. We do not merely admit it in special laws against Ireland like
the Coercion Acts, or special laws in favour of Ireland like the Land
Acts; it is admitted even more by specially exempting Ireland than by
specially studying Ireland. In other words, whatever else the Unionists
want, they do not want to unite; they are not quite so mad as that. I
cannot myself conceive any purpose in having one parliament except to
pass one law; and one law for England and Ireland is simply something
that becomes more insanely impossible every day. If the two societies
were stationary, they would be sufficiently separate; but they are
both moving rapidly in opposite directions. England may be moving
towards a condition which some call Socialism and I call Slavery;
but whatever it is, Ireland is speeding farther and farther from it.
Whatever it is, the men who manage it will no more be able to manage a
European peasantry than the peasants in these mud cabins could manage
the Stock Exchange. All attempts, whether imperial or international, to
lump these peasants along with some large and shapeless thing called
Labour, are part of a cosmopolitan illusion which sees mankind as a
map. The world of the International is a pill, as round and as small.
It is true that all men want health; but it is certainly not true that
all men want the same medicine. Let us allow the cosmopolitan to survey
the world from China to Peru; but do not let us allow the chemist to
identify Chinese opium and Peruvian bark.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account