Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
confusion and rout; and the squares of the peasant infantry would stand.
Anyhow, the first fact to realise is that we are dealing with a
European peasantry; and it would be really better, as I say, to think
of it first as a Continental peasantry. There are numberless important
inferences from this fact; but there is one point, politically
topical and urgent, on which I may well touch here. It will be well
to understand about this peasantry something that we generally
misunderstand, even about a Continental peasantry. English tourists
in France or Italy commonly make the mistake of supposing that the
people cheat, because the people bargain, or attempt to bargain. When
a peasant asks tenpence for something that is worth fourpence, the
tourist misunderstands the whole problem. He commonly solves it by
calling the man a thief and paying the tenpence. There are ten thousand
errors in this, beginning with the primary error of an oligarchy, of
treating a man as a servant when he feels more like a small squire.
The peasant does not choose to receive insults; but he never expected
to receive tenpence. A man who understood him would simply suggest
twopence, in a calm and courteous manner; and the two would eventually
meet in the middle at a perfectly just price. There would not be what
we call a fixed price at the beginning, but there would be a very
firmly fixed price at the end: that is, the bargain once made would be
a sacredly sealed contract. The peasant, so far from cheating, has his
own horror of cheating; and certainly his own fury at being cheated.
Now in the political bargain with the English, the Irish simply think
they have been cheated. They think Home Rule was stolen from them
_after_ the contract was sealed; and it will be hard for any one to
contradict them. If ‘_le Roi le veult_’ is not a sacred seal on a
contract, what is? The sentiment is stronger because the contract was a
compromise. Home Rule was the fourpence and not the tenpence; and, in
perfect loyalty to the peasant’s code of honour, they have now reverted
to the tenpence. The Irish have now returned in a reaction of anger to
their most extreme demands; _not_ because we denied what they demanded,
but because we denied what we accepted. As I shall have occasion to
note, there are other and wilder elements in the quarrel; but the
first fact to remember is that the quarrel began with a bargain, that
it will probably have to end with another bargain; and that it will
be a bargain with peasants. On the whole, in spite of abominable
blunders and bad faith, I think there is still a chance of bargaining,
but we must see that there is no chance of cheating. We may haggle
like peasants, and remember that their first offer is not necessarily
their last. But we must be as honest as peasants; and that is a hard
saying for politicians. The great Parnell, a squire who had many of the
qualities of a peasant (qualities the English so wildly misunderstood
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account