Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
About a stone’s-throw from this calamity in stone there stood, at
the corner of a gorgeously coloured flower-walk, a bust evidently by
a modern sculptor, with modern symbolic ornament surmounted by the
fine falcon face of the poet Mangan, who dreamed and drank and died,
a thoughtless and thriftless outcast, in the darkest of the Dublin
streets around that place. This individual Irishman really was what we
were told that all Irishmen were, hopeless, heedless, irresponsible,
impossible, a tragedy of failure. And yet it seemed to be his head
that was lifted and not hidden; the gay flowers only showed up this
graven image as the green leaves shut out the other; everything around
him seemed bright and busy, and told rather of a new time. It was
clear that modern men did stop to look at _him_; indeed modern men had
stayed there long enough to make him a monument. It was almost certain
that if his monument fell down it really would be put up again. I
think it very likely there would be competition among advanced modern
artistic schools of admitted crankiness and unimpeachable lunacy;
that somebody would want to cut out a Cubist Mangan in a style less
of stone than of bricks; or to set up a Vorticist Mangan, like a
frozen whirlpool, to terrify the children playing in that flowery
lane. For when I afterwards went into the Dublin Art Club, or mixed
generally in the stimulating society of the intellectuals of the
Irish capital, I found a multitude of things which moved both my
admiration and amusement. Perhaps the best thing of all was that it
was the one society that I have seen where the intellectuals were
intellectual. But nothing pleased me more than the fact that even
Irish art was taken with a certain Irish pugnacity; as if there could
be street fights about æsthetics as there once were about theology.
I could almost imagine an appeal for pikes to settle a point about
art needlework, or a suggestion of dying on the barricades for a
difference about bookbinding. And I could still more easily imagine
a sort of ultra-civilised civil war round the half-restored bust of
poor Mangan. But it was in a yet plainer and more popular sense that
I felt that bust to be the sign of a new world, where the statue of
Royal George was only the ruin of an old one. And though I have since
seen many much more complex, and many decidedly contradictory things in
Ireland, the allegory of those two stone images in that public garden
has remained in my memory, and has not been reversed. The Glorious
Revolution, the great Protestant Deliverer, the Hanoverian Succession,
these things were the very pageant and apotheosis of success. The
Whig aristocrat was not merely victorious; it was as a victor that he
asked for victory. The thing was fully expressed in all the florid and
insolent statuary of the period, in all those tumid horsemen in Roman
uniform and rococo periwigs shown as prancing in perpetual motion down
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account