Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
There is only one thing that could save my dignity in such an
undignified fix as I have fancied here. It is that Mr Bernard Shaw
himself should come to my rescue. It is that Mr Bernard Shaw himself
should declare in favour of the corpulent conqueror from the east;
that _he_ should take seriously all the fads and fallacies of that
fat-headed superman. That, and that alone, would ensure all my own
fads and fallacies being not only forgotten but forgiven. There is
present to my imagination, I regret to say, a wild possibility that
this is what Mr Bernard Shaw might really do. Anyhow, this is what a
certain number of his countrymen really did. It will be apparent, I
think, from these pages that I do not believe in the stage Irishman. I
am under no delusion that the Irishman is soft-headed and sentimental,
or even illogical and inconsequent. Nine times out of ten the Irishman
is not only more clear-headed, but even more cool-headed than the
Englishman. But I think it is true, as Mr Max Beerbohm once suggested
to me in connection with Mr Shaw himself, that there is a residual
perversity in the Irishman, which comes after and not before the
analysis of a question. There is at the last moment a cold impatience
in the intellect, an irony which returns on itself and rends itself;
the subtlety of a suicide. However this may be, some of the lean men,
instead of making a fool of the fat man, did begin almost to make a
hero of the fatter man; to admire his vast curves as almost cosmic
lines of development. I have seen Irish-American pamphlets which
took quite seriously (or, I prefer to think, pretended to take quite
seriously) the ridiculous romance about the Teutonic tribes having
revived and refreshed civilisation after the fall of the Roman Empire.
They revived civilisation very much as they restored Louvain or
reconstructed the _Lusitania_. It was a romance which the English for
a short time adopted as a convenience, but from which the Irish have
continually suffered as from a curse. It was a suicidal perversity that
they themselves, in their turn, should perpetuate their permanent curse
as a temporary convenience. That was the worst error of the Irish, or
of some of the best of the Irish. That is why the Easter Rising was
really a black and insane blunder. It was not because it involved the
Irish in a military defeat; it was because it lost the Irish a great
controversial victory. The rebel deliberately let the tyrant out of a
trap; out of the grinning jaws of the gigantic trap of a joke.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account