Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
Historians of all religions and no religion may yet come to regard
it as an historical fact, I fancy, that the Protestant Reformation
of the sixteenth century (at least in the form it actually took) was
a barbaric breakdown, like that Prussianism which was the ultimate
product of that Protestantism. But however this may be, historians
will always be interested to note that it produced certain curious and
characteristic things, which are worth studying whether we like or
dislike them. And one of its features, I fancy, has been this; that it
has had the power of producing certain institutions which progressed
very rapidly to great wealth and power; which the world regarded at a
certain moment as invincible; and which the world, at the next moment,
suddenly discovered to be intolerable. It was so with the whole of
that Calvinist theology, of which Belfast is now left as the lonely
missionary. It was so, even in our own time, with the whole of that
industrial capitalism of which Belfast is now the besieged and almost
deserted outpost. And it was so with Berlin as it was with Belfast;
and a subtle Prussian might almost complain of a kind of treachery, in
the abruptness with which the world woke up and found it wanting; in
the suddenness of the reaction that struck it impotent, so soon after
it had been counted on omnipotent. These things seem to hold all the
future, and in one flash they are things of the past.
Belfast is an antiquated novelty. Such a thing is still being excused
for seeming _parvenu_ when it is discovered to be _passé_. For
instance, it is only by coming in touch with some of the controversies
surrounding the Convention, that an Englishman could realise how much
the mentality of the Belfast leader is not so much that of a remote
seventeenth century Whig, as that of a recent nineteenth century
Radical. His conventionality seemed to be that of a Victorian rather
than a Williamite, and to be less limited by the Orange Brotherhood
than by the Cobden Club. This is a fact most successfully painted and
pasted over by the big brushes of our own Party System, which has the
art of hiding so many glaring facts. This Unionist Party in Ireland
is very largely concerned to resist the main reform advocated by
the Unionist Party in England. A political humorist, who understood
the Cobden tradition of Belfast and the Chamberlain tradition of
Birmingham, could have a huge amount of fun appealing from one to the
other; congratulating Belfast on the bold Protectionist doctrines
prevalent in Ireland; adjuring Mr Bonar Law and the Tariff Reformers
never to forget the fight made by Belfast for the sacred principles
of Free Trade. But the fact that the Belfast school is merely the
Manchester school is only one aspect of this general truth about the
abrupt collapse into antiquity: a sudden superannuation. The whole
march of that Manchester industrialism is not only halted but turned;
the whole position is outflanked by new forces coming from new
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account