Irish ImpressionsChesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
History
Irish Impressions
Chesterton, G. K. (Gilbert Keith)
Ireland -- Civilization; Irish question
directions; the wealth of the peasantries blocks the road in front
of it; the general strike has risen menacing its rear. That strange
cloud of self-protecting vanity may still permit Belfast to believe in
Belfast, but Britain does not really believe in Belfast. Philosophical
forces far wider and deeper than politics have undermined the
conception of progressive Protestantism in Ireland. I should say myself
that mere English ascendancy in that island became intellectually
impossible on the day when Shaftesbury introduced the first Factory
Act, and on the day when Newman published the first pages of the
_Apologia_. Both men were certainly Tories and probably Unionists.
Neither were connected with the subject or with each other; the one
hated the Pope and the other the Liberator. But industrialism was never
again self-evidently superior after the first event, or Protestantism
self-evidently superior after the second. And it needed a towering and
self-evident superiority to excuse the English rule in Ireland. It is
only on the ground of unquestionably doing good that men can do so much
evil as that.
Some Orangemen before the war indulged in a fine rhetorical comparison
between William of Prussia and William of Orange, and openly suggested
that the new Protestant Deliverer from the north would come from
North Germany. I was assured by my more moderate hosts in Belfast
that such Orangemen could not be regarded as representative or even
responsible. On that I cannot pronounce. The Orangemen may not have
been representative; they may not have been responsible; but I am quite
sure they were right. I am quite sure those poor fanatics were far
nearer the nerve of historical truth than professional politicians like
Sir Edward Carson or industrial capitalists like Sir George Clark. If
ever there was a natural alliance in the world, it would have been the
alliance between Belfast and Berlin. The fanatics may be fools, but
they have here the light by which the foolish things can confound the
wise. It is the brightest spot in Belfast, bigotry, for if the light
in its body be darkness, it is still brighter than the darkness. By
the vision that goes everywhere with the virility and greatness of
religion, these men had indeed pierced to the Protestant secret and the
meaning of four hundred years. Their Protestantism is Prussianism, not
as a term of abuse, but as a term of abstract and impartial ethical
science. Belfast and Berlin are on the same side in the deepest of all
the spiritual issues involved in the war. And that is the simple issue
of whether pride is a sin, and therefore a weakness. Modern mentality,
or great masses of it, has seriously advanced the view that it is a
weakness to disarm criticism by self-criticism, and a strength to
disdain criticism through self-confidence. That is the thesis for which
Berlin gave battle to the older civilisation in Europe; and that for
which Belfast gave battle to the older civilisation in Ireland. It may
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account