Isabel of Castile and the making of the Spanish nation, 1451-1504Plunket, Ierne L. (Ierne Lifford)
History
Isabel of Castile and the making of the Spanish nation, 1451-1504
Plunket, Ierne L. (Ierne Lifford)
Isabella I, Queen of Spain, 1451-1504; Spain -- History -- Ferdinand and Isabella, 1479-1516
If, in matters of practical administration, the sovereigns accepted
their duty of obedience, like certain brides, with reservations, they
did not let their enthusiasm for Catholic dogma blind their eyes to the
scandals of the Roman Court, and more especially to the evil reputation
it acquired during the pontificate of Alexander VI., the notorious
Rodrigo Borgia. Conscious of the harm his example wrought in the Church,
they sent private ambassadors to petition him that he would send away
his children from Rome, “purify his life, reform his house, and cease to
allow the sale of benefices and ecclesiastical offices.”
That their motive was a genuine desire to raise the prevalent low
standard of morality may be gathered from their rigorous policy of
ecclesiastical reform at home. Hitherto all efforts in this direction
had proved abortive; and the instructions issued by Alonso Carrillo,
Archbishop of Toledo, at the Council of Aranda in 1473 show how
deep-seated was the evil. Open immorality of life and more venial
habits, such as dicing and the wearing of gaily-coloured clothes are
amongst the ordinary offences scheduled; but even the standard
recommended for the future scarcely touched a high level. Bishops were
not to take money in return for conferring ordination, nor to accept as
fitting candidates those unable to speak Latin, the language of the
Church. Priests must celebrate Mass at least four times a year and
bishops three, while both were strongly urged not to lead a riotous or
military life. The latter charge, as emanating from Don Alonso Carrillo,
has its humorous aspect, but criticism was disarmed by the grave
addition, unless it should be to take service with kings or princes of
the blood.
The character of the episcopate, in whose hands these measures of reform
were left, fully explains the failure that attended them. An Alonso
Carrillo could not be expected to quench military tendencies; an Alonso
Fonseca, the giver of banquets, to suppress luxury; a Pedro Gonsález de
Mendoza to inveigh heavily against broken vows of celibacy. This Queen
Isabel realized, and with the exception of Cardinal Mendoza, her
advisers in spiritual matters were men of a very different type.
“He is a gentle-natured priest, somewhat narrow of mind perhaps, but a
sound theologian without bitterness or passion.” Thus wrote Peter Martyr
of Fra Fernando de Talavera, Isabel’s confessor, who exercised so large
an influence over her mind throughout the earlier part of her reign. The
story of his introduction to his duties is characteristic of both man
and Queen. At their first confessional, the Friar, seating himself on a
low stool, bade his companion kneel before him; but she, unwilling to
lower her dignity, reminded him gently that it was the custom for her
confessors also to kneel.
“Señora,” replied Fra Fernando, “this is the tribunal of God, and
therefore must you kneel and I be seated.”
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Elsewhere in the archive
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account