John Bull, Junior; or, French as She is Traduced — John Shaqi
John Bull, Junior; or, French as She is TraducedO'Rell, Max
General
John Bull, Junior; or, French as She is Traduced
O'Rell, Max
French language -- Study and teaching
This young man, I hear, is also going to be a missionary. The news goes
far to reconcile me to the noble army of John Bull's colonizing agents,
but I doubt whether the heathen will ever get much entertainment out of
him.
* * * * *
Some boys can grasp grammatical facts and succeed in writing a decent
piece of French; but, through want of literary perception, they will
give you a sentence that will make you feel proud of them until you
reach the end, when, bang! the last word will have the effect of a
terrible bump on your nose.
A boy of this category had to translate this other sentence of
Dickens:[2] "She went back to her own room, and tried to prepare
herself for bed. But who could sleep? Sleep!"[3]
[2] "The Old Curiosity Shop."
[3] Here I have to make a painful confession. I have actually
acceded to a request from my American publishers, men wholly
destitute of humor, to supply the reader with a translation of
the few French sentences used in this little volume. This
monument of my weakness will be found at the end.
His translation ran thus: "Elle se retira dans sa chambre, et fit ses
préparatifs pour se coucher. Mais qui aurait pu dormir? _Sommeil!_"
I caught that boy napping one day.
"Vous dormez, mon ami?... _Sommeil_, eh?" I cried.
The remark was enjoyed. There is so much charity in the hearts of boys!
Another boy had to translate a piece of Carlyle's "French Revolution":
"'Their heads shall fall within a fortnight,' croaks the people's
friend (Marat), clutching his tablets to write----Charlotte Corday has
drawn her knife from the sheath; plunges it, with one sure stroke, into
the writer's heart."
The end of this powerful sentence ran thus in the translation:
"Charlotte Corday a tiré son poignard de la gaîne, et d'une main sûre,
elle le plonge dans le coeur de _celui qui écrivait_."
When I remonstrated with the dear fellow, he pulled his dictionary out
of his desk, and triumphantly pointed out to me:
"WRITER (substantive), _celui qui écrit_."
And all the time his look seemed to say:
"What do you think of that? You may be a very clever man; but surely
you do not mean to say that you know better than a dictionary!"
Oh, the French dictionary, that treacherous friend of boys!
The lazy ones take the first word of the list, sometimes the figurative
pronunciation given in the English-French part.
Result: "_I have a key_"--"_J'ai un ki_."
The shrewd ones take the last word, to make believe they went through
the whole list.
Result: "_A chest of drawers_"--"_Une poitrine de caleçons_."
The careless ones do not take the right part of speech they want.
Result: "_He felt_"--"_Il feutra_"; "_He left_"--"_Il gaucha_."
With my experience of certain French dictionaries published in England,
I do not wonder that English boys often trust in Providence for the
choice of words, although I cannot help thinking that as a rule they
are most unlucky.
Public-domain text, read in full here on John Shaqi.
Reviews
Reviews
No reviews yet
Be the first to share your thoughts on this work.
Join the Discussion
Join the discussion
Sign in to leave a comment or review.
Sign InorCreate an account