[339] Innoc. III. _Epp._ l. vi. No. 167. R. Coggeshall, p. 135, dates this appeal a year too late. The Pope, on the authority of Philip himself, speaks of it as having been made “more than a year before” Philip issued his citation to John, a citation of which the date is by other evidence fixed at the end of March or early in April 1202. [340] _Rot. Pat._ vol. i. p. 2, dateless, but as the document is on the roll of John’s second year, its date must be before May 3, 1201. From its position on the roll, it would seem to belong to October 1200. [341] R. Howden, vol. iv. p. 160; R. Coggeshall, pp. 128, 129. [342] _Rot. Chart._ p. 102. [343] R. Howden, vol. iv. pp. 160, 161. [344] _Ib._ p. 163. [345] _Ib._ pp. 163, 164. [346] _Itin._ a. 3. [347] R. Howden, vol. iv. p. 161. [348] Innoc. III. _Epp._ l. vi. Nos. 163, 167. [349] Cf. R. Howden, vol. iv. p. 164; Rigord, c. 135; Gerv. Cant. vol. ii. p. 93; and for dates, _Itin._ a. 3. Rigord’s “pridie Kalendas Junii” is doubtless a mistake for “Julii.” [350] Innoc. III. _Epp._ l. vi. No. 167. [351] _Itin._ a. 3. [352] R. Howden, vol. iv. p. 176. [353] _Ib._ [354] W. Brito, _Philipp._ l. vi. vv. 106–43. [355] Gerv. Cant. vol. ii. p. 93. Hubert crossed on December 14, R. Diceto, vol. ii. p. 173. [356] _Rot. Pat._ vol. i. pp. 5, 6. [357] Cf. Gerv. Cant. vol. ii. p. 93; R. Diceto, vol. ii. p. 174; Rigord, c. 137; and R. Wendover, vol. iii. p. 167. John was at Orival on March 23; then there is a blank for three days, and on March 27 he appears at Les Andelys, _Itin._ a. 3. [358] _I.e._ on April 28. The date is from Rigord, c. 138. [359] R. Coggeshall, pp. 135, 136. Cf. Rigord, c. 138; W. Armor. _Gesta P. A._ c. 110; Gerv. Cant. vol. ii. p. 93; and Innoc. III. _Epp._ l. vi. No. 167. [360] R. Coggeshall, p. 136. [361] Rigord, c. 138; W. Armor. _Gesta P. A._ c. 110. Cf. Gerv. Cant. vol. ii. p. 93, and Innoc. III. _Epp._ l. vi. No. 167. [362] R. Coggeshall, p. 136. [363] See “The Alleged Condemnation of King John by the Court of France in 1202,” in _Transactions of the Royal Historical Society_, new series, vol. xiv. (1900), pp. 53–68. [364] Gerv. Cant. vol. ii. p. 93. [365] Innoc. III. _Epp._ _l.c._ [366] Cf. Gerv. Cant. vol. ii. p. 94; Rigord, c. 138; W. Armor. _Gesta P. A._ c. 112; and R. Wendover, vol. iii. p. 167. [367] Innoc. III. _Epp._ _l.c._ [368] The war had begun before May 11, _Rot. Pat._ vol. i. p. 10. [369] Cf. Rigord, c. 138; W. Armor. _Philipp._ l. vi. vv. 204–20, and R. Wendover, vol. iii. p. 167. [370] See _Itin._ a. 3, 4. [371] R. Wendover, vol. iii. p. 167; for dates cf. _Itin._ a. 4. Gerv. Cant. vol. ii. p. 94, places this siege too late. [372] R. Howden, vol. iv. p. 115. [373] _Chron. Britann._ a. 1201, in Morice, _Hist. de Bretagne, preuves_, vol. i. cols. 6, 106. [374] _Rot. Pat._ vol. i. p. 7. [375] Delisle, _Catalogue des Actes de Phil.-Aug._, No. 726.